Am I the only one who disagrees?
From my experience, I never found a set of Pachmayr grips that I liked. Could be that my first impression was a lasting one, but when it comes to aftermarket grips, I just don't like those Pachmayr's.
Aside from that, my only problem with the Super Blackhawk in recoil was with the trigger guard coming back and kissing my knuckle. That dragoon style guard drew blood nearly every time I fired the gun. This might have something to do with the fact that I was 12 or 13 at the time, but once again - first impressions...! Years later, I fired a FA 454 with the stock grips, and I came to realize just what that style grip was for.
So I say, let that hawgleg roll back in your hand. If you must, dehorn (or replace) that guard, and maybe replace those grips with aftermarket grips, only nicer ones. Ruger does tend to skimp a bit in the grip department. But leave the gun in the original configuration, I think it works better.
Just my opinion, and Good Luck!
Unkel Gilbey