I always thought fitting was necessary.
Can you just try it?
You might get lucky and have it fit, but there are multiple considerations that make it unlikely. You will need to be concerned about:
Overall cylinder length (has to fit the window. Too long can be shortened, too short might be able to be shimmed)
Barrel-cylinder gap. Tough to fit by hand, especially since the magnum cylinder fits and you can't tinker with the barrel to compensate
Chamber-to-barrel alignment. The locking notches have to stop the cylinder in alignment with the bore
!!Yeah they want more to fit a cylinder and shipping than I paid for the gun
But Pietta can't. And since I have fitted replacement cylinders to Pietta and Uberti six shooters, I can state definitively that they are not drop-in parts.Hawg Haggen said:Well it would be a sad thing indeed if a top notch U.S. company can't have machinery precise enough to make thousands of the same thing exactly alike so they're a drop in fit but an overseas co. like Pietta that makes cheap reproductions can.
The people responding in this thread were trying to help you avoid personal injury. But, you took an ignorant stance, and are now treating them like they are attacking you.
But Pietta can't. And since I have fitted replacement cylinders to Pietta and Uberti six shooters, I can state definitively that they are not drop-in parts.
I glad to hear that everything worked out for you.Sorry if I came across like that. I finally got my old model single six cylinder. It fits and functions perfectly in my new model. Timing is perfect, cylinder gap is 0.003 which is exactly the same as the magnum cylinder it came with.