I would be surprised as well
Once again Im amazed at reports such as yours about poor quality from Amadeo Rossi, which is now a subsidiary of Taurus Interntional. As Ive stated in earlier posts, Ive owned guns from both makers...a stainless Rossi Bulldog and a Taurus .38 Ultralite snubby. I was extremely pleased with the quality of both guns. Both functioned flawlessly right out of the box. While its true that both makes had QC problems in the past, both have been brought on a par with other brands in recent times. A NIB gun should never have any problems that can be detected simply by inspecting it at the dealers counter, and if it does it shouldnt be on the dealers shelf. I certainly would pass on such a lemon too. Having said that, if you bought one and later found it to be less than acceptable, I would be surprised if Taurus would not correct the problem at no further cost to you. In fact, I bet they would refund your shipping costs as well. They do have an ironclad warranty.