Revolver Durability

JoeSeidel

Inactive
I just started going to the range, and althrough I have several revolvers and several semiautos they were never fired much. Never had parts break on either type of pistol. On the Semiauto Forum there is a tread on Semiauto Durability -- many claim that 300,000 rounds can go through 1911 frames, and the guns work continue to work fine. I was wondering about revolvers' durability. I have several Ruger Security Sixs and Single Action Revolvers. Has anyone put thousands of rounds through these type of pistols with little wear and no problems.
Thanks.
 
Revolver durability will depend on several factors.
1. Quality of construction and materials
2. Ammunition. High pressure ammo will accelerate wear
3. Proper maintenance
4. Type of shooting. Fast-n-furious double action shooting puts more wear on the revolver than slow and deliberate fire.

That being said, most revolvers will out live their owners.
 
Sitting here with a paperweight......

The paperweight is a Smith & Wesson .32 "Safety Hammerless/New Departure revolver......

It was made sometime in the late 1890's.....

Still works fine.......

I don't have any idea when it will get worn out.

Also have a Colt 1851 Navy cap&ball .36 revolver, made in the 1860's......

It too still shoots.......

Don't know when that one will get worn out either.

I think you may ruin a good handgun with abuse, but I doubt that anyone can afford enough ammunition to wear one out.
 
If you compete often then you will probably wear out gun eventually if your using a 357, 41, 44, or 45LC with magnum level loads most of the time. That is if you do all of your shooting with just one or two guns.

Have you ever replaced parts as part of regular maintenence? If you haven't and you haven't had any break then you probably don't need to worry about it since your not shooting often enought with any particular gun to wear it out.

BTW 1911's are not going to shoot 300,000 rounds without replacing many parts. What they mean is that they have kept same frame while replaceing springs, extractors, pins, barrels, etc.

Kinda like runing a car for 300,000 miles you can certainly do it without replaceing engine if you repair & maintain it. Though miles to bullets is apples vs oranges...with cars miles don't matter (to engine) as much as total revolutions which depend on gearing and etc.

Shooting full power loads in a gun is like running car at higher rpm (ie racing or no overdrive) while light loads are like cruising at idle rpm.
 
Didn’t notice that slight exaggeration, and given the order of posts I thought you meant me. As I’m pretty sure you know, the last time the military bought new 1911-A1 pistols was 1945, although they kept rebuilding them through the middle 1980’s - maybe later, after the Beretta was adopted. I know some of these guns that were used in training and fired continuously, had over 100,000 rounds through them (by “guns” I mean frames) and were still working after several complete rebuilds. I always thought this was interesting because about 95% or more of those frames were made during World War Two out of relatively soft steel. The parts used in rebuilding them were much better, but even so…..

The military also made special match grade pistols at Springfield and Rock Island Arsenal(s). Those in the hands of shooting teams had a lot of rounds put through them, and usually after one year were returned, stripped, rebuilt and refinished. But I would hesitate to cite a number like 300,000 rounds….

Several champion IPSC shooters have claimed to have “worn out” pistols, but I think what they mean is that the gilt-edge accuracy they demanded was gone, not that they had shot the pistol to the point of self-destruction.
 
Reminds me of Geo. Washingtons hatchet. The handles broke a couple times and been replaced and the heads worn out and had to be replaced but it's the very same hatchet.:D
 
Joe Seidel

I have put at least 15,000 factory equiv 44 magnum handloads thru a S&W 44 mag 6.5 inch 629 Classic Dx. I noted a little loosening of the cylinder latch-lock mechanism but the revolver fired accurately without problem. I confess after 15,000 rounds I traded the gun for a new model 629 Classic Dx.
Herb
 
There seem to be two extemes in the replies to the original question. Interestingly enough, both are correct.

Yes, if you shoot moderate loads and shoot deliberately (moderate stroke of the trigger if DA or moderate cocking of the hammer if SA) a well made revolver will probably last as long as you do.

On the other hand, if you shoot a lot and shoot it hard (heavy loads and fast shooting/handling) you can wear out a revolver in a season.

Cases in point:

A good friend of mine got into the Cowboy Action Shooting game and in addition to shooting in two or three matches each month, practices his "rapid fire" single action technique weekly. After replacing springs and parts several times he gave up on the SAA clone he had worn out in one year and went to a less traditional Ruger Vaquero just for the incresed durability.

My first duty weapon (Deputy Sheriff) was a S&W Model 28. I fired a minimum of 100 rounds per week (on my own time) with Magnum reloads, all fast double action. By the time I got off probation (at least 5000 rounds, maybe more) the M28 was out of time and suffered considerable endshake. It needed major repairs. I switched to a 1911 and never went back to revolvers for duty (still like them and own and shoot them but understand their limitations).

Any gun will wear out. The more parts in the design, and the more carefully fitted those parts are, the sooner it will show signs of use - hard use just accelerates this process.
 
Back
Top