I recently ended up with a Fobus paddle holster for my Kimber. It's a very affordable paddle holster that carries nice and light, and has been very durable thus far. It's only a week old, but I'm pleased with it so far.
I usually prefer the leather option. Don Hume makes pretty good ones.
However, Galco has introduced a Paddle Lite for most brands. It's pretty cheap, and I haven't had anything Galco that I've been disappointed in. I'd suggest those three options.