I'd look at libertysafe.com. They also deliver from local authorized dealers if that could be a problem for you. Liberty has imported models too at a lower price. You could easily spend a little more than $1K, but get something worth the investment. Fire rating doesn't mean fire proof, but it will buy you time if something bad happens. If you live in a rural area, a longer rating would be a good idea.
Most important to me specifically is total weight and speed of access. If someone wants to steal it while you aren't home and they want it bad enough, they'll get it. Why not make it harder for them and get a real heavy safe!
Electronic key pads are great for speed.