Recoil control, how do you rate these svc. calibers?

[long shot]

When fired from same or similar guns, using full power ammo, how would you rate the following: .40/357 sig/9mm/.45/10mm?

Knowing recoil is a subjective issue, I'm curious to see if individual answers differ much.

Best To All!
{long shot}

 

[FUD]

<OL TYPE=1><LI> 9mm
<LI> .40S&W
<LI> .45ACP
<LI> 10mm</OL>Never fired a .357SIG but I suspect that it would be around the .40 (either right above it or right below it).
Share what you know, learn what you don't -- FUD

 

[long shot]

Fud, I have fired a few rounds of 125gr GD through a P229, & would qualify it's recoil & muzzle blast as "sharper" than the .40's.

1. 9mm
2. 40
3. 45*
4. 357sig
5. 10mm

*To me the .45 in most pistols seems to recoil a little more than the .40, except when fired from a G-21 or G-30, those are two sweet shootin' .45's.

Best, long shot!

 

[PreserveFreedom]

1) 9mm
2) .45ACP
3) .40S&W
4) .357Sig
5) 10mm

 

[johnwill]

1) 9mm
2) .45ACP
4) .357Sig
3) .40S&W
5) 10mm

 

[Rob96]

9mm - easiest

.45acp - In 1911's and a S&W 645

.40auto - In a Glock 22, did not like the snappy recoil, also had a stinging feeling to it. But thats just me.

 

[Richard]

1) 9mm
2) .45ACP
3) .40S&W
4) .357Sig (thunder and lightning in Glock 27 sized pistol))
5) 10mm I have never shot a 10mm so I have to go by reports I have read.

Regards,

Richard

 

[WESHOOT2]

9mm
45ACP
40 S&W
10mm

no experience with 357 SIG

------------------
"All my ammo is factory ammo"