Reason why you bought a brass framed BP revolver

What is the main reason you bought a brass framed BP revolver?

  • I like the bright shine of polished brass.

    Votes: 2 7.1%

  • As a "southerner" I wanted to have a replica of a confederate BP revolver.

    Votes: 2 7.1%

  • It was the cheapest BP revolver I could afford at the time.

    Votes: 9 32.1%

  • It was the only thing available in the store when I went shopping for BP revolvers.

    Votes: 1 3.6%

  • I have a collection of BP revolvers and no collection is complete without one or more.

    Votes: 6 21.4%

  • Other reason - tell us what compelled you.

    Votes: 8 28.6%
  • Total voters
    28
  • Poll closed .
C

ClemBert

New member
A brass framed BP revolver is pretty low on my list of priorities. There are a lot of other BP revolvers I'd rather buy first. For some of you it was one of your first purchases. So the question is: What was the reason you bought a brass framed BP revolver?
 
I've got a Dance and a couple Leech & Rigdons. Having at least one of each that my Southern ancestors used means I need a brass framed Schneider & Glassick, Griswold and Gunnison, and a Spiller and Burr; as well as iron framed Tucker and Sherrod, and LeMat.
 
I've got a Dance and a couple Leech & Rigdons. Having at least one of each that my Southern ancestors used means I need a brass framed Schneider & Glassick, Griswold and Gunnison, and a Spiller and Burr; as well as iron framed Tucker and Sherrod, and LeMat.
Click to expand...

Hmmm, need a Starr and an Adams is a must. Maybe a Manhatten and a Bacon.
 
Last edited:
You mean to say they make BP revolvers with brass frames??? :D

I much prefer steel frames but like most, the two brass framed ones that I have (early Navy Arms short round barreled '51 Navy style and a ASM '62 Pocket Police) I bought because I had a weak moment and the price was low enough that I couldn't pass them up. I have just as much fun shooting them as I do my steel frames . . . . and after all . . . that's what it is all about - fun! The cheaper brass frames are an easy way for a beginner to get their feet wet and see if they like the hobby or not and some folks just like the looks of them (they can be handsome!). As I said, it's all about fun and after 45+ years of shooting BP, I'm still having fun! :)
 
I don't have one, but if the price was right, I wouldn't hesitate to jump at it. I don't supersize my loads, so I wouldn't be worried about blasting one apart.
 
Hawg Haggan said:
Hmmm, need a Starr and an Adams is a must. Maybe a Manhatten and a Bacon.
Click to expand...

And there's also the Whitney, Shawk & McLanahan, Cofer, Columbus Firearms Manufacturing Co, Kerr English revolver, Deane English revolver, and Tranter English revolver; but they don't make replicas of those. Cost of having a 'complete' collection of Southern used revolvers would be prohibitive - unless I hit the Powerball lottery.
 
I chose other.

It was actually a couple of reasons combined, it was cheap, it was there, and it looks pretty whether polished up or somewhat tarnished.

I've always liked brass in general, its just a good looking metal with tons of character.
 
They are pretty to look at and fun to shoot. As long as you keep the charge relativly low there is no problem. I don't have one, but my friend does. I had my Ruger Old Army and he had a 1858 Remington. We shot it with about 25 grains and it shot just as well as mine...

There is absolutly nothing wrong with a brass framed gun, you just can't fill the chamber to the brim with powder and cram the ball in like you can with a Ruger Old Army...

I'm looking to buy a 1851 colt pretty soon with a brass frame. It looks great and it a classic. I'm not going to shoot the snot out of it, just once a month or so and put a few rounds through it. If thats all you are doing, a brass frame will hold up just fine. :)
 
I would LIKE to purchase one, one day, so I can risk bunging it up to experiment with timing, and trigger smoothing and one to just experiment with in the exercise of gunsmithing. It would be nice to have as a spare as well so that when you go shooting a friend can use it. Or even better, one can BRIBE a person with a bit of land outside of the city to "go have some fun and shoot BP".

Another good reason for me to purchase one is to simply have another arm around as a backup for the Remmie I will one day get.

In my opinion, one could never have TOO MANY brass remmies.
:D
 
My only brass-frame C&B revolver at the moment is a Navy Arms Reb, a fair copy of a Griswold and Gunnison. It was cheap and I wanted a Confederate-style revolver. I wouldn't pass up a Spiller and Burr at the right price. Since I have several steel-framed guns to shoot, my favorite being the 1860 Colt repros, so the brass-framed one(s) are shot a little and enjoyed a lot.
 
Southern roots

Have a Griswold & Gunnison, Schineder & Glassic, Leech & Ridgon, Spiller & Burr. Would like a LeMat, and a .36 Dance. (Have to go to England for the Dance. Henry Krank has them.)

Have a great 4th!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

P.S. My GGGGG uncle was M.A. Baker of Fayetteville N.C. He converted a lot of flintlocks to percussion for the Confederacy.

Andy
 
And there's also the Whitney, Shawk & McLanahan, Cofer, Columbus Firearms Manufacturing Co, Kerr English revolver, Deane English revolver, and Tranter English revolver; but they don't make replicas of those.
Click to expand...


I don't believe they make clones of the Sherrod or Tucker either but you mentioned them.:p:D
 
I got it for free. That seemed like the right price to me. It's a lot of fun to shoot. I keep the powder charge at around 20 grains of 3F so there's no worries about damaging the frame. When I take it to the range it seems to always attract some attention because it looks like something straight out of a Clint Eastwood movie.
 
Hawg Haggan said:
I don't believe they make clones of the Sherrod or Tucker either but you mentioned them
Click to expand...

Uberti made some Sherrod & Tucker repros. Madcratebuilder managed to pick up a cased set one last year & there was an NIB one that went on GB last year for around $500 IIRC. I'm still on the lookout for one.
 
Did someone mention a Tucker & Sherrard 2nd model Colt Dragoon?

texasdragoon2.jpg


Uberti made these for Western Arms out of NM.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top