9.3X62 reamer
Dear Nick:
I believe I get your drift! You're refering to the old 45-70 I think and that we got there first! I agree!
Also, all over the world during "black powder days" countries used large bores that despite what the modern scribes say - did deliver good "knock-down" effect.
Yes, and I agree with Cooper that we should have stayed with the 45ACP for the military!
As for European theory, yes, I think they are baseing alot of their experience on heavy dangerous game (let me agree with you that a 45-70 is a fine heavy-game cartridge) and thought that penetrating the game completely was desireable disabling lungs and passing body fluids! Of course correct bullet selection is of prime importance!
I early noticed this with muzzle-loaders! The large caliber round-ball has, for me, anchored more game very quickly! Even, I must admit, on poor shot placement at times my 50 round ball always got me a hog.
Yes, I've built and have high intensity cartridge rifles, but seriously, if I had to cross the country (not able now) as our forefathers did I'd carry a flint 54 cal. muzzle-loader with a bag of balls (they had them too) and powder and flint!
Nick, I think this is your drift - I apologize if I've mis-read you.
Harry B.
P.S. Nick, I do use a 22-250 for hogs now - when I hunt them
- I've got so I don't want to shoot anything but cats now!