I think for most people, the best gun to learn on is not necessarily the best gun for them after they graduate from the beginner status. I learned to shoot initially with a pellet gun. I like the standard Buckmark .22, and so do my friends that I have introduced to shooting. Yes, it has a more complicated manual of arms than a revolver, but I think the combination of the light trigger pull, the light recoil, the good sights and the barrel length make it fun for everyone. I agree that beginners respond most favorable when they can hit something pretty easily, heck that's still exciting for me. I think a longer barreled .22 breaks them in gently and teaches good habits. Best of all, when she is ready to move up, you can just keep your new plinker. Seems like a great reason to buy a S & W model 41, you know, not for yourself, but for the wife. Wink,wink. Nod,nod.