p228 p229 in 9mm

T

temp

Inactive
What is the difference between the sig p228 and p229 in 9mm?

I did a search on this forum, and read that the p229 has a stainless slide (to accomodate the .40S&W and .357SIG) but the p228 does not have a stainless slide. Some people were saying that the p229 felt top heavy in 9mm because of the added weight of the stainless slide. And some people were saying that the p228, since it doesn't have a stainless slide, wears out after awhile and isn't as reliable.

I'm looking into getting one of these 2 for me and my wife. Any input? Thanks.
 
I have a 229 in .40. It's my understanding that the 229 with its stainless slide was developed from the start to handle the stouter recoil of the .40 round. It was later converted to 9mm. The 228, on the other hand, was designed as a 9mm from the start, thus the different materials. I also know that the 228 has slide cocking serrations that are the full height of the slide, while the 229 only has them about half the height of the slide.

If you're looking at a .40, get the 229. If you want a 9mm, I think the 228 is the way to go. As a defensive weapon, I don't see much of an upside to getting the 9mm, though. With hi-caps, you're giving up one round, and with 10 rounders nothing. The .40 is generally a better round if you don't mind the recoil and added expense, and both the 228 and 229 are heavy enough to handle that recoil.
 
Temp,
The 228 in 9mm is lighter & a little more balanced then the 229 in 9mm or 40 because of the materials.The 228 also has the roll pins which some people say can work their way loose...I never had a problem with that & have never seen it happen.The 229 with its stainless slide should be a little more durable but who really knows...both will last a lifetime...I just ordered a Two-Tone 229 in 40 w/Siglites last week,I cant pick it up until next payday...That sucks...Anyway...One nice thing about the 229 in 40 is that you can get the .357sig & the 9mm barrel for it...If I was going to shoot 9mm only I would get the 228 but if you want to shoot multiple calibers go with the 229 in 40...Either way you cant go wrong...Sigs kick ass...Good luck :)
 
The slide of the P228, as with the early P22X series before it, is (at least I'm sure it is still 'is' and not yet 'was') made of stamp formed sheet metal with a bolt assembly pinned into it. The front portion fo the slide around the muzzle is also welled and ground to the proper profile. The slide of the P229, designed for the .40SW from the start, is milled out of a solid block of steel to accommodate the higher pressure round. No sheet metal, no welds.
 
Greeting's All,

I agree with most of what has been
said; but some of the information has been
formed from opinion's, instead of
fact's.:( In the case of the P229, it is
slightly "top heavy"; making the P228 a
much better balanced weapon.

I can't confirm the information posted
regarding the P228 containing bolt's and weld's. If this is true, at least mine
doesn't show it.:):D In a previous post, I
stated my W. German P228 had recorded
approximately 2500 rounds without a hiicup.
These weapons, as imported from W. Germany
are utterly reliable; so, I will stand by
my statement. So, in closing I'll say if
you want the extra weight, improper balance
and such buy the P229; but if you like true
craftsmanship, buy the P228. You won't regret
it one bit!!!

Respectfully,
Ala Dan, Life Member N.R.A.
 
So I heard there are two different p228's? One of them a German made and assembled, and the other one German made but assembled in the US? Which one is better?
 
For a 9mm pistol, the P228 has better balance, but the P229 has better recoil control because of the weight differences. If you're looking for a compact 9mm SIG pistol the P228 is my favorite.

Dan - If you field strip your P22* series pistols and look at the underside of the slide just where the rails start you will see a slightly ground weld. The slide is a three piece deal before welding, finishing and finally having the breachblock pinned into it. They have always been this way, it's just really subtle.
 
Thanks blades, I'll check it out-

but it really doesn't matter to me,
one i-o-da; cuz I still love 'em
just the same.:D:)

Wishing All A Happy & Safe Labor Day Week-End

Ala Dan, Life Member N.R.A.
 
Dan - If you have one with a blued slide you can also find the seam on the external side of the slide if you look very carefully.

It doesn't bother me either. My P220 will out shoot a number of "custom" 1911's as it came from the factory.:cool:
 
etron,

Sig's come in several finishes; a blued slide is simply the
color of the slide. In other words, its not bright or matte,
not nickel, and not stainless steel. However, on the P229
standard finish is of a blued stainless slide. Some of the
weapons made by Sig, also come with what is known as
K-Kote; supposedly a clear, protective barrier against
rust and corrison. Hope this helps.

Best Wishes,
Ala Dan, Life Member N.R.A.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top