+p or no +p
I messed around with all sorts of .45 ACP loads for decades. After spending a lot of time and money with various bullet shapes and weights, both factory and handloads, I finally decided to become realistic.
Standard stuff is usually best---certainly simpler. I measure factory ammo against 230 gr. hardball at standard velocities. Unless doing the most precise possible methods, it is difficult to tell which target was shot with Federal,R-P,or Winchester ammo.
Many years ago, I adjusted my practice handloads, 230 RN cast, 230 RN plated, and 230 RN jacketed, so that they all hit pretty much the same point of impact as the factory ammo. Happily, I found that Speer Gold Dot 230 HP standard velocity impacted right in there with that same ammo.
I sometimes have to look for the GDHP which is NOT the Plus-P load. No problem. I'm retired and kind of enjoy shopping at ammo suppliers. The
GDHP (and factory FMJ) standard velocity loads are adequately powerful without the max velocity "advantage." They are easier to shoot well and don't batter my pistols as much.
A five-inch Government Model or even a 4.25-inch barrel Lightweight Commander are sufficient with standard velocity ammo. Yeah, when I pack a snubby .38 Spl or a compact 9mm, the +p ammo is something of a comfort, but I don't feel the need with a .45 ACP.
For whatever its worth, my handloads are for practice or hunting. I carry factory ammo when I go out in public.
Best regards
JPG