Simon, He went for the "texas heart shot" which I also talked to him about as a good way to ruin meat or poorly wound with buckshot. He tried to lead right thinking it was going to take an opening to the right but it did the lean right and fake left turn. He barked an oak tree but we still spent 20 minutes making sure we didn't miss blood. We tracked to a 5 foot fence into a hunt lease where the deer turned and went to a lower spot and jumped.
We had 3 spaces of 25 to 40 feet wide on clay to track it and had no blood (I know that isn't a 100% guarantee) nor did we have and unusual hoof prints like a limp or bum hip.
I am quite confident he missed clean.
He has spent the summer weekend nights with a bunch of deer doggers who run their dogs in preparation for season. They talked of running shots and the need for buckshot.
He just jumped the trigger in haste. Thus the lecture about slob shots and ethical hunting.
When he asked why I didn't try on the deer I seen, I told him "Son, I don't take any shot that I am not sure will drop the deer or give me the best chance of a blood trail. I also do not take shots at deer at a far distance if that deer is on a woods edge as it may be too far into a swamp to trail it up."
Plus I am not 100% healthy so I am suffering pain no matter the distance to drag/carry so the closer to the truck, the better...
Brent