NYC cabdriver fights back but...

Jffal

New member
Not sure which newspaper pro gun ownership Libertarian talkshow host Irv Homer (WWDB 96.5 FM) read the incident from but it apparently happened very recently. A search on the net for documentation proved futile, though I suspect something solid will be posted soon. Irv provided names on both individuals but I neglected to write them down.

The story went like this - a cabbie got into a dispute with his passenger over the fare. The passenger attacked the driver with a knife. The cabbie disarmed his assailant and used the knife against the fellow, landing the passenger into the hospital. The assailant was charged with assault, deadly weapon, etc etc. But, because he used the passengers' own knife against him, police charged the cabbie with using a deadly weapon.

The mind boggles. The only thing I can think of, unless there is critical information not revealed in that article,is that the DA (he ultimately sets the charges?) felt that the situation was under control once the assailant had been disarmed and that the cabbie's actions amounted to overkill.

Incredible.
Jeff
 
I have a buddy that had this happen.

He was mugged at knife point. Two bad guys against him and his girlfriend.

During a scuffle, one bad guy stabbed my friend and left the knife in his gut.

My buddy pulled out the knife and stabbed the guy in return.

My buddy got THREE YEARS for ADW because the jury found that "once he had the knife, he had control of the situation, and should have sat down and waited for the ambulance to come".
Once he had the knife, he had the deadly weapon and the bad guy no longer did. So, at that instant he was stabbing an unarmed person who posed no immediate deadly threat to him.

Unfortunatly, that is reality and I think it SUCKS.
 
Back
Top