Does "BG" mean Bowling Green?
If so, then consider heading down to north side of Findley to Jaqua's shop,
They would probably help in types you should consider.
Have you done any shot-gunning, trap, skeet???
Just trying to get a feel for recoil you can handle.
Also for NW ohio deer, you may need to consider using the sabot shell to give you more range, as that area is a tad open, with isolate woodlots.