New: ordinance gelatin kit!

adad

New member
I’ve wanted to test my favorite self-defense ammo (147 gr. Speer Gold Dot JHPs) in a block of 10% ordinance gelatin for a while now. At first I had no idea what this stuff was, how to get it or how to prepare and use it properly. After finding and reading Shawn Dodson's instructions on a simplified method for preparing 10% ordinance gelatin, the only thing holding me back now is the cost.

The ordinance gelatin is only available from the manufacturer and you have to buy a minimum of 25 pounds, which costs $275 (plus shipping). Then you have to find or make a mold the right size to get a block of gelatin measuring 18x6x6 inches. Shawn Dodson (of Firearms Tactical Institute ) had a custom, stainless steel mold manufactured by a local sheet metal shop for $60.00. That's over $335 just to get started! At that price I don’t think I’ll be testing my ammo with ordinance gelatin any time soon.

However, this is something I really wanted to do so I did some asking around and this is what I’ve come up with. I’ve figured out that I can put together a kit that would include a rugged, 18x7x6 inch polyethylene gelatin mold and enough ordinance gelatin powder to make a block measuring 18x6x6 inches for a very reasonable price -- if there are enough people who are interested in a kit like this.

In order to do this, though, I have to do it big -- I have to order a lot of gelatin powder at once, pay for the tooling costs for the plastic mold, etc. The up-front investment it will require on my part isn’t small, but I’m willing to do it if there’s enough interest. I figure I can make these kits available to anyone who's interested for about $39.00 each. Don't forget that with proper care and handling (and propionic acid, which is not included in the kit -- see below for a source), the gelatin can be recycled and re-used many times.

Another possible option is to use two .50 caliber ammo cans as molds and lay the two gelatin blocks end to end. This will take about 3 lbs of gelatin powder (this is a little more powder than it takes to make a 18x6x6 inch block). For those who would rather go this route, I could supply the 3 lbs of ordinance gelatin for about $29.00.

Please respond to this post if you would seriously consider participating once I've determined that there's enough interest for me to go ahead with this. Just to clarify: this is only a survey, not a request for orders. Responding to this post in no way obligates you to purchase anything.

Comments, suggestions and questions are all welcome.

*****
NOTE: If you participate in this survey by responding to this post, I will enter your handle in a drawing to give away a free kit (assuming there's enough interest for me to go forward with this little project!)
*****

IMPORTANT! --->
Some important qualifications: you must have a chronograph to properly calibrate the gelatin or the results will not be valid. If you don't have a chronograph or know someone who does, consider getting a ProChrono Pal for about $85 here. The kit also does not include the propionic acid that you will need if you want to recycle the gelatin. Shawn Dodson has a source where it can be purchased. You can find it in his instructions on a simplified method for preparing ordinance gelatin here.

BTW: I strongly recommend that anyone interested in getting and using ordinance gelatin for terminal ballistics testing of handgun ammunition read Shawn’s detailed instructions. He does a great job showing exactly how to prepare and properly use the ordinance gelatin in order to get valid results. Even if you don't get the gelatin to do your own tests, I think you will find it very interesting and informative.

Thanks for your help!
-adad

------------------
If you value your right to keep and bear arms, support Citizens Of America -- they're doing it right!
Wound Ballistics is the study of effects on the body produced by penetrating projectiles.
Great Daily Commentary from a thoughtful Christian perspective.
Some fascinating insights into the current market mania from the Prudent Bear fund.

[This message has been edited by adad (edited May 16, 2000).]

[This message has been edited by adad (edited May 16, 2000).]

[This message has been edited by adad (edited May 17, 2000).]

[This message has been edited by adad (edited June 02, 2000).]
 
Yup. I'd be interested.

Rick

------------------
I prefer armed combat to unarmed combat. It's easier on the knuckles.
 
Thanks for the reply, Rick. Please keep checking back here as, hopefully, we get more interested parties speaking up. I'm a bit concerned about being 'way out here in the nether-world of forums (this seems to be a pretty dark and lonely spot -- you can almost hear the echo... echo... echo... :) ), but hopefully more people will find their way out here. Of course, once (if?) we reach critical mass, I'll send out a note to everyone who posts here letting them know when we'll be getting under 'way if they want to participate.

Thanks again,
-adad

[This message has been edited by adad (edited May 15, 2000).]
 
Per an emailed and logical request from adad, I am moving this back to the Handguns forum. It is reasonable that handgunners would be most interested in this.
 
So how much should I expect to pay for enough gelatin to stop a 400gr .45-70? ;)

Oops, this is in Handguns... uh...

So how much should I expect to pay for enough gelatin to stop a 400gr .45-70 out of a Freedom Arms revolver? :D
 
Me too, JDThaddeus! I hope others feel the same way. The way I see it is this: no one else is going to test the ammo of your choice in your own gun for you.

NOTE: I will not be able to access the internet for a few days, but I will answer any questions when I can get back on-line.

Thanks everyone who has replied for your support! If you know anyone else interested in doing this, please encourage them to respond to this post.
 
adad,
When you say a lot of kits, how many are you talking about? (50, 100, 500) You would think you could substitute something for the mold other than having a tool (mold) made. What if you used 6" PVC drainpipe for instance, and then cutoff whatever length you needed. You could make a simple cradle out of plywood or whatever to keep it from "rolling" away. (Like a big V-block) A 10' section of 6" diameter solid PVC drainpipe sells for about $25 and endcaps are around $4. That's about $5 a mold. Maybe I'm missing something. Just a few of my thoughts.
Regards,
SM
 
Thanks for the detailed info G35. After reading your post on Glocktalk, I realized that a flexible plastic mold would be better, so I got another quote on what it would cost to make the molds using a thinner sheet of polyethylene, which would make the mold less rigid and provide some flexibility; it also dropped the cost for each mold. I updated the cost for the complete kit (see my original post) to $39 -- that includes the gelatin and the mold.

BTW: The amount of gelatin included in this kit is 2.5 lbs. According to your post on glocktalk this amount of gelatin would cost about $35. For $4 more you get a mold the proper size as well.

As for finding a plastic container with the proper dimentions to use as a mold -- please let me know if there is such a thing (for a reasonable price). Keep in mind that the mold's dimentions (18x7x6) are pretty important. In discussing the size of the mold with Shawn Dodson, he was quite adamant that the 6x6 inch face of the gelatin block not be reduced (for various reasons). The depth of the mold, if it can't be 18 inches, should be around 9 to 10 inches so two blocks can used together to get 18 to 20 inches or so of penetration depth. But most people already have or can get a mold with these aprox. dimentions -- .50 cal. ammo cans. Which is why I am offering the gelatin-only option for $29 --it takes about 3 lbs of gelatin for the two ammo cans. Just as a comparison, 3 lbs of the gelatin you recommend in your post would cost about $42.

One quick note: the difficult and time-consuming process of slicing the gelatin and measuring the cracks created by the temporary cavity that you describe in your post is really not necessary. There is plenty of medical evidence that the temporary cavity caused by a typical handgun cartridge does not contribute to its wounding capabilities (see IWBA's journal -- you can get back issues at www.iwba.com ; also, the book "Bullet Penetration" has a very detailed discussion on this and other factors; and, of course, the www.firearmstactical.com web site has great information, including some articles from the IWBA). The two critical measurements from each test firing are just penetration depth and the expanded diameter of the slug.

[This message has been edited by adad (edited June 02, 2000).]

[This message has been edited by adad (edited June 03, 2000).]
 
<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by Airborne:
adad,
When you say a lot of kits, how many are you talking about? (50, 100, 500) You would think you could substitute something for the mold other than having a tool (mold) made. What if you used 6" PVC drainpipe for instance, and then cutoff whatever length you needed. You could make a simple cradle out of plywood or whatever to keep it from "rolling" away. (Like a big V-block) A 10' section of 6" diameter solid PVC drainpipe sells for about $25 and endcaps are around $4. That's about $5 a mold. Maybe I'm missing something. Just a few of my thoughts.
Regards,
SM
[/quote]

Airborne,

That's an interesting idea I hadn't thought of, but I think it would be too labor intensive to be practical for me -- I'm looking at doing 200 to 400 at a time. Also, the requirement of a cradle would keep it from being an out-of-the box solution, which is what I wanted.

But I won't rule it out entirely -- I'll give it some more thought. It certainly doesn't have the start-up costs of the custom-made mold!

Thanks for your suggestion.
 
Back
Top