New Gun - S&W 340PD Range Report

goosevr1

New member
I recently purchased a S&W 340PD for carry. I had been carrying a Glock 22 in an IWB holster but the weight and size of the 340PD was very appealing. I purchased it new for $590.

Right out of the box, I was amazed at the sheer weight of the thing. At 12 ounces unloaded, it's half the weight of my glock and a fraction of the weight of my 1911's. It can sit in the pocket of a pair of pajamas without any discomfort. With a decent pocket holster (in this case a Galco pocket holster) there were times when I've had to feel around just to make sure I still had it. Very pleased with the weight and carry-ability/concealment.

Before I took the pistol to the range, I had dry fired it numerous times to get a feel of the action. While I'm not new to pistols, this was the first revolver I've purchased. As I left to head out to the range, I dimmed the room lights to simulate a little "low-light exercise" when I noticed a few sparks in the barrel. With a bit futher inspection, I noticed that every time I pulled the trigger sparks would appear from the firing pin hole. This was made known to me as there was a large wall mirror in the room I was practicing in, not because I deliberately looked into the barrel. Nevertheless, I phoned S&W before leaving for the range and they told me that this wasn't normal and that they were sending me a Fedex packing slip so that I could send them the weapon back.

I was disappointed. I hadn't fired a single round and I was looking at shipping it back to the manufacturer already. I checked a few forums again and only found that someone else had the problem in the past--no resolution. Regardless, I took the gun to the range anyways.

Since I expected the 340PD to have a good amount of recoil, I only took with me 50 rounds (45 Winchester White Box 38 special, 5 Federal Hydrashok) and the pistol ate through all these without a problem (I suppose it is a revolver after all...)

At the time, the gun still had the factory grips on it (so the entire backstrap was exposed). Firing 150gr .38 special loads really wasn't too much of a problem for me (5'10" 170lbs). The recoil is pushes into your hand more than snapping your wrist upwards. I was able to shoot all 40 rounds comfortably and probably could have shot another box without much difficulty.

The 158gr .357 mag loads out of the 340PD is an entirely different story. These go off with a big boom and you feel it. A lot of people have described it as catching a fastball without a baseball glove and that's pretty much what it feels like, it smarts. However, I didn't cut me..it didn't bruise..and I didn't feel any different the next morning when I woke up. Yes I only fired 5 rounds, but this gun was not made to be a range gun anyways.

With a pair of overmolded rubber grips, felt recoil is significantly reduced (Currently using Crimson Trace laser grips). .357 mag is still not pleasant to shoot, but I can put a few cylinders down range at the end of my range time without feeling too bad about it.

For what it's worth, I got this particular pistol for CCW and can't be any happier with it. The weight allows you to carry it pretty much anywhere without having feel like you're carrying. With pocket/ankle/other holsters widely available, I have a carry setup for almost every situation and clothing attire I own.

While I wouldn't recommend this as a 1st gun or as a gun for beginners, I think most people with CCW in mind would enjoy this particular weapon.


Hope this helps and stay safe.
 
I had been planning to "upgrade" my SW 442 for a 340 for some time, but I decided to stick with 38sp when I found a lone remaining 342pd at a local shop. I'll maintain an interest in the revolver, tho, and look forward to reports by you and others who have followed-through and actually bought this little tiger.
 
Before I took the pistol to the range, I had dry fired it numerous times to get a feel of the action. While I'm not new to pistols, this was the first revolver I've purchased. As I left to head out to the range, I dimmed the room lights to simulate a little "low-light exercise" when I noticed a few sparks in the barrel. With a bit futher inspection, I noticed that every time I pulled the trigger sparks would appear from the firing pin hole. This was made known to me as there was a large wall mirror in the room I was practicing in, not because I deliberately looked into the barrel. Nevertheless, I phoned S&W before leaving for the range and they told me that this wasn't normal and that they were sending me a Fedex packing slip so that I could send them the weapon back.

Prior to firing any rounds through this weapon, I would reproduce this sparking each and every time I pulled the trigger. Now that I've put 100 rounds or so down range, I only see this spark through the barrel 1 out of every 9 or 10 shots (on average). I had called S&W on Thursday so I haven't gotten the shipping label yet but I'll have to call them tomorrow and speak with a smith. I'm hoping that as the gun "breaks-in" this problem will resolve itself as that's what it looks like. Regardless, I will keep this thread updated in case anyone else has this problem in the future. I hope it fixes itself, I never really like sending firearms back and forth through the mail.

Another few rounds down the range today, new grips haven't arrived yet. Brought 10 full house .357 mags and a box of WWB. As expected, the mags still hurt but I decided that I should know what firing 5 of them in a row felt like since I carry .357 mag hydrashoks for CCW. It doesn't make you bleed or anything but you certainly feel it and you mentally you sure go "ouch." Firing any more than 10 rounds of full house mags in any given range session is too much (unless you're a recoil junkie).
 
Called Smith and Wesson today and spoke with a Gunsmith (19 yrs experience building S&W's he says). In his opinion, he says that this may be due to a fit issue or the presence of some burrs around the area. I was told that I should continue to "break in" the gun (so put another 400 rds through) and see if the problem continues.

They already sent me a call tag and fedex shipping label; he said it was okay for me to hold on to it and send it back if the problem didn't resolve itself. Not too big a problem he claims.

Well, I'll keep the thread updated. It might be a while for 400 rounds, these ultralight SC snubbies have quite a kick and I don't usually put more than a box downrange during any given range session.
 
I'd send it back, if it were my gun. Sparks from the firing pin sounds like excessive pin contact, i.e. excessive pin wear. It probably won't make any difference to the operation of your handgun, but I'm uber picky with my CCW guns.
 
I had the same exact problem in my 340pd. Its my first revolver so I didnt know it wasnt normal. I plan to break it in and see if it still does it.

What problem could the spark cause anyway?
 
The sparking eventually goes away. I dried fired the crap out of my 442 and it doesn't spark anymore. It's going just over 2000 rounds right now and I've had no problems. So just click away. It's good for you and the gun's lockwork anyway.
 
I had the same exact problem in my 340pd. Its my first revolver so I didnt know it wasnt normal. I plan to break it in and see if it still does it.

What problem could the spark cause anyway?

Hypothetical situation: You're at the gas station pumping gas into your vehicle. It happens to be a Suburban with a 25 gallon gas tank and while pumping you realize the auto fuel clicker thingamajiggy does not stay enagaged so you have to stand there manually. Its at this time you're sitting there humming a little diddy in your head and then the idea hits you....I know, I've got my new ccw piece on me (and its empty- take it for what its worth;hypothetical) and its tirgger is tight and throws sparks upon enagagment. So there you are standing at the pump, dry firing away like a madman, sparks going here and there, breaking in the trigger of your new handgun....humming a little diddy...all of sudden because you're having the time of your life snapping away you don't realize the gas tank has filled up and it overflows as the shutoff valve is late in cutting out the fuel flow....at this time you're in mid pull on trigger and the thought of "oh 5h17, I shouldn't have done that" crosses your mind just as the hammer breaks...........It *could* happen....
 
Hypothetical situation: You're at the gas station pumping gas into your vehicle. It happens to be a Suburban with a 25 gallon gas tank and while pumping you realize the auto fuel clicker thingamajiggy does not stay enagaged so you have to stand there manually. Its at this time you're sitting there humming a little diddy in your head and then the idea hits you....I know, I've got my new ccw piece on me (and its empty- take it for what its worth;hypothetical) and its tirgger is tight and throws sparks upon enagagment. So there you are standing at the pump, dry firing away like a madman, sparks going here and there, breaking in the trigger of your new handgun....humming a little diddy...all of sudden because you're having the time of your life snapping away you don't realize the gas tank has filled up and it overflows as the shutoff valve is late in cutting out the fuel flow....at this time you're in mid pull on trigger and the thought of "oh 5h17, I shouldn't have done that" crosses your mind just as the hammer breaks...........It *could* happen....

LOL!!!
I realize you are joking but seriously, if I was that stupid I would much rather put the gun to my head and get my miserable life over with.
 
I am puzzled by S&W's verbal response to you about this issue. I have seen threads about this phenomenon on a few gun boards. It's nothing new.

I've had my S&W 340PD for over a year now. When it was new, I noticed the same sparking from the firing pin hole in the frame. I wasn't particularly alarmed because my 10 year old S&W 640 .357 did the same thing when new. My new S&W 638 did it for a while, but it has since stopped.

My recommendation... Don't fret about it.
 
Catbird, I'm also puzzled by S&W response as well, though I guess I can't say I'm surprised. From what I've seen, it's a common phenomenon that I'm sure they are aware of.
 
Back
Top