As far as quality of extensions go, I'd put Remington factory, Scattergun Tech, and Choate tied in first.
I put Tac-Star in second place.
Choate makes one of the very best. Their's has been around almost as long as the Remington factory unit, and it's well-proven.
An advantage to the Choate unit is, it comes as a complete kit. You get the extension, the longer spring, a heavy-duty magazine follower, a sling swivel, AND the critical barrel clamp.
USE THE CLAMP.
It doesn't matter HOW strong the extension is, it's still screwed to the thin magazine tube on the gun, and it's VERY possible to knock the extension loose, OR OFF entirely.
Give the unsupported extension a fairly minor bump, and it can get either knocked out of line, jamming the magazine, or worse, knocked off the gun completely.
The clamp stabilizes and supports the extension.
The Tac-Star and Scattergun units don't come with a clamp.
Choate's come in capacities from 7 total for an 18" barrel, to a 10 shot total for a 26" barrel, AND come in blue or parkerized finish.
A 8 shot unit will fit a 20" barrel, NOT the 18" barrel of the Express HD.
Be sure to match the extension to the barrel you have.
The absolute BEST price I've ever found on Choate products is:
Eldon King. Email--
gunrunner@cox-internet.com
He sells Choate units for prices LESS than the "discount" prices charged by anybody else I've found.
The sporting fore end on the Express is longer, so longer side saddles won't work. You can either, shorten the stock fore end, replace it with a Police-length fore end, or use shorter side saddles.
One "watch-out" with side saddles. DON'T over tighten the unit on the receiver. This will compress the receiver and cause jams.
Make SURE that when the slide is ALL THE WAY BACK, there is still at least a tiny gap between the saddle and the fore end.
If the fore end is bumping the saddle, this can cause jams, and is hard on the gun.