My new Steyr M40 replacement pistol -- and a new test (long).

Emin

New member
A Steyr M40 that I purchased a few months ago had its serial number starting with 001. I absolutely loved the way this pistol shot; however, I experienced:

A. frequent (every 6 or 7 rounds) misfires;
B. ejected brass leaving marks on the slide;
C. the mags wouldn't go in smoothly as if something was stopping them half way through;

The correction of the problems B and C was, of course, up to the GSI gunsmith. The misfiring, on the other hand, had to be more or less described to him first. After very carefully analyzing the problem, I came to a conclusion their cause could have been one of the following being faulty:

1. ammo -- CCI Blazer 180 gr and Speer Lawman 165 gr

2. the firing pin

3. positioning of each round -- it may sound strange, but most of the misfired cases had a light indentation off its center whereas all the normally fired cases had a deep indentation dead in center

I immediately ruled out the ammo. I regularly practice with these brands, and other pistols I own have NEVER experienced misfires. So, it was either 2 or 3.

Thus, I send the pistol to GSI with a letter of the problems' descriptions. It came back in about a week, and I took it to the range as soon as I could.

Once there, I found out the ejected-brass-scratching-the-slide issue remained despite that GSI modified the pistol's ejection port. Apparently, at least in my case, it didn't make any difference whatsoever. I decided to let it go since to be truthful, it hadn't bothered my shooting that much in the first place.

They corrected the problem with the magazine catch which functioned flawlessly now.

The misfiring remained. It occurred less frequently but enough for me to be concerned. I seriously planned to make this gun my CCW for colder months and couldn't afford such an obvious malfunction.

As a result, I contacted the company one more time and spoke to Herbert Wohlmuth (a very courteous guy, BTW). He told me to send the pistol to them again, but this time he was going to replace it for a new one. He said a new shipment from Austria was suppose to arrive soon, so one of them would be my new replacement.

I send the gun on January the 27th; it came back last week. Don't get me wrong -- I'm not complaining because the shipment was really badly delayed (work of the #*&%$@& liberals, perhaps?).

My new Steyr M40 has the serial number starting with 005 and its ejection port modified. More specifically, one of its edges as well as all the corners are cut out at 45 degrees. Both mags go in very smoothly with no stoppages along the way. I could hardly wait to take this puppy to a range the very next day.

Out of 250 rounds of CCI Blazers 165 gr TMJ, I experienced 5 misfires. All had exactly the same profile as before. That, of course, upset me enormously until I suddenly noticed a single detail which explained everything. It was, most likely, the cause of all the misfires with my first Steyr, but I simply didn't pay enough attention to notice it. Who would have thought?..

For all of you guys who own Steyr M-series pistol -- with a round in the chamber and the gun, of course, "cocked" (can't really call it like that with Steyr and Glocks, or can I?) and ready to fire, try to pull the slide backward just a little bit, not even enough for the ejection port to open. If you had the same frustrating misfiring problem and unless the real cause of yours is something completely different altogether, you'll be surprised to discover that the slide ... will stay in that position. The recoil spring simply doesn't have enough strength to counteract the firing pin spring which, when the striker's "cocked", acts in the exactly opposite direction, that is, pulling the slide backwards.

It won't happen with an empty chamber. Apparently, even a little resistance of a round being inside and rubbing against the breech face, feeding ramp, and extractor is JUST ENOUGH to even both springs' forces and keep the slide NOT to go into full battery.

Apparently, it's enough for the slide to stick backwards as little as roughly 1/8 of an inch for the pistol to misfire.

When you pull the trigger in this situation, the slide will move forward into full battery first (you won't hear it at a range, or like in my case, may not see it due to deem light) and then make this weak "click" so typical of a regular healthy misfire. Disgusting.

Another package to GSI? I decided to discuss it with a local gunsmith first. What could be done to make each round create less resistance once in the chamber? The breech face on my Steyr is as polished as it can be, so that's out. The feeding ramp? BTW, it's my strong opinion that the Steyr barrel are THE most sturdily constructed, finely machined, and thick-walled I've seen in any pistol. Their feeding ramps are extremely smooth already.

Which brought us to this freaking loaded-chamber indicator gizmo. In a nick of time, its pin that normally protruded from the breech face was filed off, I and tested the pistol one more time. 100 rounds -- 1 misfire. Down to 1 %. Still not satisfied.

The gunsmith did some file job on the extractor after that which was the last thing to try (my other hypothetical thought, of course, might have been "making" the chamber unsupported, but to be honest, I got my Steyr to avoid buying a Glock). I went to a range tonight and shot 200 rounds. One misfire. We're getting better.

Sorry for the long post guys, but I just thought any additional piece of info would be useful for all the owners of this new weapon.

I'm definitely sticking with this gun. You want to know why? At the range today, I did something I'd long thought incapable of doing -- less than 2 inches at 25 yards. What a feeling!

That's all for now, but I'll keep you posted. .

[This message has been edited by Emin (edited March 09, 2000).]

[This message has been edited by Emin (edited March 09, 2000).]
 
Thanks for all the information. I've been tracking the M40 on this BB and other ones since before Christmas because I liked all of the features I had read about this gun. I checked out a M9 at a store and found that ergonomically the Steyr fit me perfectly. The only rub I had was that the trigger pull felt quite heavy, about 8 lbs I would guess. I recently checked out an M40 at a shop and found the trigger to be even worse. It wasn't just heavy, it seemed to have an initial resistance to pull through before the final stage of relasing the striker. Two triggers on basically the same gun(M9 and M40) that were so different raised concern about the QC at Steyr. The problems you had with yours is not good. I would expect a company to burn some ammo in testing a gun that was sent back to ensure reliable functioning. The tweaking you had to do was something that should have been done at the factory on each gun they were shipping out.

Although I'm still interested in this gun I don't believe it should be encumbent on me to have to ship it back to the factory for a problem they should have fixed. I like the 40S&W caliber and own a USP40C and a Glock 23. Neither one had to go back to the factory. I would trust my life to either one since they are supremely reliable--straight from the factory. I'm going to wait on buying an M40 for some of these QC problems to be resolved.

------------------
 
Emin, thanks for the info. This sounds disturbing to me. I have about 500 rounds through my M40 so far and have had exactly zero malfunctions of any sort. I will see if I can replicate the failure you describe when I go shooting this weekend.

Mikie, I also examined several M40s at stores before getting the one I have. There does indeed seem to be some variance in the triggers that can't be explained by the two different trigger weights available from Steyr. One gun I examined had a pull much heavier than the 7.8-8 pounds alleged to be the heavy version.

I still like mine tremendously, but I'm going to keep an eye on these problems. Has anyone else seen the problem with failure to go into battery?
 
David,

Regarding replicating the problem -- I thought if I limp-wristed the gun, it would do that. So I tried; however strange, my Steyr refused NOT to go into full battery.

It's really weird, but it seems to me the only way for my gun to misfire is if I manually pull the slide slightly backwards. When I did that, the failure replicated precisely just as it happened by itself. I knew that I risked a potential KB! by doing this, but I was frustrated enough, so I did. In these cases, the gun misfired very consistently. How it really happens during shooting, I simply don't know.
 
Interesting. I had the same problem with my M9 but didn't know enough about the gun to describe it as accurately as you have. Although the one time it happened I didn't get a firing pin mark on the primer at all. Thanks, I will include this detailed description when I send my gun in. The main problem I am still having is that it is not always resetting the trigger saftey (as I reported some time ago). Its somewhat rare, but it does happen.

Also, had an interesting thing happen my last trip to the range. I loaded some 147 gr. Gold Dot JHPs. They fired fine. Then, for some reason, my friend asked me to stop for a second. I took out the magazine and tried to eject the round in the chamber -- and the slide was stuck! These rounds had fed and fired and ejected fine, but I could not manually eject the round. It took my friend and I both pulling on the slide together, him pulling back the front of the slide and me the back (very carefully, pointed down range the whole time, finger off the trigger, etc.) to actually eject the round (we were worried at this point about firing the round to get it out). Very strange. BTW -- tried this with 115 gr. FMJ and not a problem. Not good since I expect to be able to use JHPs for personal protection.
 
Funny My $325 S&W sigma 40v suffers from none of the problems I hear abou this new steyr or about the glocks.

Yet everyone seems to discount the sigma except people who own them and have fired at least 500 rounds through them.



------------------
Master Blaster
 
Back
Top