I appreciate everyone's feedback. I had the feeling it looked too regular as well. To "age" it, I threw it in the driveway and ran it over a bit with the Gator, beat the edges on a cement post,then tried to add random toolmarks, scratches, etc. If I could do it again, I think I'd do the running over, use a lighter stain, and do without the tool marks. I kinda figured this wouldn't be everyones cup o' tea, but again I appreciate all the feedback.