hotdogs - what you're saying is if it has a bayonet lug, then it is a HW? I thought all 590's came w/ the lug option...
inSight-NEO - I take it from your post that you had a "standard wall" barrel & went to a HW barrel. Does your standard wall have a bayonet lug? Also, if your HW barrel looks to be roughly 1/8in thick... "eye-balling" the standard barrel... the thickness would be... ?
Also wondering why go HW barrel? Is the SW barrel not strong/tough/durable enough, especially in 3" Mag?
To answer/comment in order: I believe that the bayonet lug is primarily available for the 9-shot 590's, both the Special Purpose and the A1.
Yes, I replaced my thin walled barrel with the heavy walled version. In terms of thickness, the thin walled barrel looks to be roughly half the size...1/16" maybe? Again, this is give or take approximation.
Try this...Take a look inside the muzzle end of the bore and see/feel if there are any threads (from the front bead sight) protruding into the bore. If there are..it is most likely the thin walled barrel. The reason I mention this is that the "stock" bead sight, along with the Meprolight tritium sight I now use on the thin walled barrel, had at least one thread poking down into the bore. With the heavy walled barrel, both sights (threads) were flush or better; hence, no threads protruding into the bore.
If all else fails, as I mentioned earlier, just search the receiver for the words "590 A1." If you do not see them, you probably have the standard thin walled barrel.
Also, I traded "up" for two reasons: 1). Due to a careless gunsmith armed with a dremel, the bore of the original barrel was scratched all to heck (still useable by all means...just not pretty) and 2) I wanted a barrel that could truly be considered "heavy duty" and far less likely to burst under pressure. Sure, this may be a somewhat paranoid reason, but I think of the shotgun as a "heavy duty" type weapon..therefore, I have set myself to making it as heavy duty as Mossberg parts allow, so to speak. For this reason, in addition to the HW barrel, I also added a metal trigger assembly and safety button. Hence, at this point, I basically have converted my "standard" 590 in to an A1. This just suits me better.....
Of course, all of this has less to do with necessity and more to do with "want." Does one need the HW barrel? Nope. Does one need the metal trigger assembly? Nope. Does one need the metal safety button? Well, possibly...
I guess I could have just bought a 590 A1 to begin with, but I couldnt find one locally and even if I had, the wait would have been over 3 to 4 months or so.