(MI) Engler set to sign CCW bill into law

Oatka

New member
Lots of good info here even if you aren't from Michigan. They have, for instance, John Lott's new column on Wakefield.

Anybody who has a few bucks would find them well-spent with this effective organization. And, in the meantime, contact Gov. Engler and support him (info at end of article).

http://www.mcrgo.org/

By Sara Scott, Booth News Service

LANSING - Concealed weapons permit-holders won't be able to legally carry a weapon into a Michigan casino, bar or sports arena.

But, they will be able to carry them into party stores, malls and even some dance clubs.

Gov. John Engler this weekend is expected to sign a bill that revamps Michigan's concealed weapons law, making it easier to obtain a permit but restricting where weapons are allowed.

Though controversial, the "CCW Free Zones" were key to the bill's passage.

"It was a compromise," said Rod Collins, a spokesman for the Michigan Coalition of Responsible Gun Owners. "No one got everything they wanted ... But this was the version that the lawmakers could live with."

Once signed, the bill will make Michigan a shall-issue state, meaning county gun boards must grant permits to applicants if they are 21, have no recent criminal history, no mental problems and can successfully pass a training course. Now, local gun boards have discretion in granting CCW permits, and applicants are required to show a need.

The bill also creates several gun-free zones: schools, day care centers, hospitals, college dormitories and classrooms, churches, casinos, bars, restaurants that serve alcohol, and stadiums and arenas with a capacity of at least 2,500.

A permit-holder caught carrying a weapon in a gun-free zone could face a $500 fine and a six-month permit suspension.

Businesses that aren't included in the gun-free zones are certainly free to post a no-guns-allowed sign, but violators can't be prosecuted under the law, said Rep. Michael Green, who sponsored the bill.

"They could kick someone out, sure, but that's about it," said Green, a Mayville Republican.

Several businesses, including some adult entertainment clubs, fall just outside the requirements for gun-free zone status.

Brad Shafer, an attorney who represents Deja Vu, a chain of alcohol-free adult entertainment clubs, said gun-related trouble is a concern for all entertainment facility operators.

But, at Deja Vu, there hasn't been gun-related trouble.

"In general, the men don't come to an adult entertainment club looking to joust, they come here to look at the women," Shafer said. "You're more likely to have trouble in a bar ... where there's a lot drinking going on."

The gun-free zones were a sticking point in legislative debate of the controversial bill. Engler had said he would not sign it unless the zones were included.

Zone proponents say it will reduce the chances of a gun-related tragedy. Opponents say the designation may have the opposite effect.

"We call them 'victim zones'" said Collins. "It's like advertising to criminals that there aren't any law-abiding citizens with guns in these places."

Green said he's fairly confident that most permit holders would have a clear understanding of where it is legal to carry their weapon, because the information will be covered in a required training course. He said he was worried that some current permit-holders, who will be grandfathered in, may not be aware of the new rules.

Engler received the bill Dec. 19 and has until Tuesday, or two weeks from that date of receipt, to sign it. A spokesman said the governor would sign the bill sometime this weekend.

The bill takes effect July 1.

According to recent figures from the Michigan State Police, there are about 51,000 CCW permits in Michigan. Of those, about 21,000 are nonrestricted, allowing holders to take their guns anywhere. It's difficult to say how much that number will grow under the new law.

Opponents of the bill have launched a campaign to reverse the new law by taking a referendum to voters in 2002.

"We'll start gathering signatures in early January," said Carolynne Jarvis, the executive director of the Michigan Partnership to Prevent Gun Violence. "We have no intention of letting the grass grow."

Contact Sara Scott at (517) 487-8888 or e-mail her at sscott5669@aol.com.

Contact Governor Engler's office at 517-373-3400 and indictate your support for his signing the legislation. The anti's are definitely calling to rail against it.
 
It will be up to your state to determine if it will accept a Michigan CCW/CWP. Michigan accepts everybody's permits now.
 
Sounds like a lot of victim-disarmament zones. I'd be afraid that I'd forget one of them and make a mistake.

A CCW holder in my state told me about going into the post office, forgetting that he couldn't carry there, until in line and saw a sign regarding no carrying. He was ticked. He quickly left, but wished they'd put a sign on the front DOOR, not only inside!!

--Denise
 
Sounds like too many place not to go. Here in Indiana, It is just the Post Office, Schools, banks, etc.. I would also be interested in what the definition of a "day care center" is.
 
Here in Utah, we (CCW holders) can carry in schools and banks, AFAIK. Just not federal buildings.

A couple of months ago, anti's were working hard to collect signatures for an initiative that would prohibit carrying in schools and churches. I'm soooo thankful their signature drive failed.

My pastor's take: "I'd feel safer if someone in my congregation was carrying." The fellow doesn't own any handguns, but does own and run a hunting camp in Colorado. :)

--Denise
--------
Great homeschool curriculum: http://www.KONOSetc.com
 
sbryce,

My understanding is that the Bank law is a federal law. I just heard second hand that I couldn't carry in a bank. I never actually saw the law in print.

Also the school law is a federal law but is not being enforced. The original law was turned over in court and a new law (an exact copy as I am told) was then passed but it is not enforced. Instead local laws are enforced instead to "protect" the federal law from being challenged.
 
gunpowder

The quick answer is found at http://www.packing.org/state/utah/, with attendant disclaimers. Again, this is Utah.

"Where should I not carry? The concealed firearm permit only exempts the permit holder from three laws: carrying a concealed and loaded firearm in a vehicle; carrying a concealed firearm on your person and; carrying a loaded and concealed firearm on or about school property. All other state and federal laws still apply. Such as, you may not carry a firearm in secured areas of an airport and you may not carry a firearm in secure federal buildings. These areas should always be posted. But please be aware of these restrictions in case they are not."

Guess I'd better keep hunting as regards the bank question. A secondary issue to me is the status of credit unions. I don't frequent banks. There's been a major feud between credit unions and banks here, and I need to know if the federal laws regarding banks also cover credit unions in this instance. In many other instances they don't.

--Denise
 
SBRYCE,
"an airport
a school,
a riverboat casino (Title 68, Indiana Gaming Commission,
Article 1, General Provisions Rule 7 b & d), and
Some have reported that any place with a posted sign
forbidding weapons is off-limits, but some say that these signs hold no authority, but one reader has refuted that. The entire state law is at this link, when I find time, I will post an updateto my search."

This was listed under Indiana. Ssys nothing about banks, etc. but I know that Indinaan has a "school law" so I presume only state laws are listed. It would be interesting to find a site listing federal laws. Thanks for the Link. I had another one of similiar design bookmarked.
 
The Veto

This is good news for Michigan, however Engler also vetoed anther bill, the Vear Transportation Act. From Engler's letter:


John Engler
Governor
January 2, 2001

Michigan House of Representatives
State Capitol Building
Lansing, Michigan 48913

Ladies and Gentlemen:

Today I have vetoed and am returning to you herewith,
Enrolled House Bill 5432.

Enrolled House Bill 4532 would amend the Michigan Penal Code to allow a person to carry or
transport an unloaded pistol in a wrapper or container in the trunk of a vehicle for any reason. It
would also allow a person of any age and for any reason to transport an unloaded pistol in the
passenger compartment of a sport utility vehicle, pickup truck, van and other vehicles not equipped
with a trunk if the weapon is not readily accessible to the occupant(s).
The term "readily accessible" is not defined and is
ambiguous at best.

More importantly, the bill would eliminate existing
requirements that a pistol be transported only for explicit lawful purposes. Currently, there are strict
guidelines for transporting weapons in a vehicle. Michigan State Police Uniform Crime Report data
reveals that during the past three years, over 18,000 suspects were arrested for a weapons offense.
Many of these arrests were for unlawfully carrying a pistol in an automobile. I share the concern with
law enforcement officials that this legislation would allow potential criminals to lawfully transport a
weapon to the scene of a crime.

The bill, if enacted, would also contravene a corresponding provision found in Section 12a(h) of
Enrolled House Bill 4543, which I have signed into law this date. That provision provides for the
transportation of an unloaded pistol in a locked compartment, not just a wrapper or container as this
bill purports.

END

NOTE: Text of Section 12a(h)
Sec. 12a. The requirements of this act for obtaining a
license to carry a concealed pistol do not apply to any of
the following:
(h) A person while carrying a pistol unloaded in a wrapper or container in the trunk of his or her
vehicle or, if the vehicle does not have a trunk, from transporting that pistol unloaded in a locked
compartment or container that is separated from the ammunition for that pistol from the place of
purchase to his or her home or place of business or to a place of repair or back to his or her home or
place of business, or in moving goods from 1 place of abode or business to another place of abode
or business.


There is also a campaign under way to have the appropriations section of this bill removed. If this happens, the law may not go into affect until it has been voted on, providing there are enough petition signatures.

It looks like the battle is on.
 
Utah Code 53-5-710:

A person with a permit to carry a concealed firearm may not carry a concealed firearm in the following locations:
(1) any secure area prescribed in Section 76-10-523.5 in which firearms are prohibited and notice of the prohibition posted;
(2) in any airport secure area as provided in Section 76-10-529;
(3) in any house of worship or in any private residence where dangerous weapons are prohibited as provided in Section 76-10-530; or
(4) at an Olympic venue secure area in violation of Section 76-10-531.
 
Back
Top