favorite
A Marlin 1894 .357 is one of my favorite carbines. I've used a variety of bullet weights and styles, from .38 WC through .357/158-160 gr slugs.
Only troubles I had was with certain flat nosed SWC in magnum cases, and .38 WC. Never tried WC in mag cases but I suspect that would be cranky as well.
I played the field power wise too. The .38 WC made an ideal practice round for new shooters making the jump from .22. Then hot +p+ .38/110's, mag 125's, which were duty rounds for us in the revolver days. The .357/125 combo was formidable and hugely destructive in tissue on pests and varmints. Likely a bit fragile for a deer load, but I have no doubt a 125 JHP mag load from a carbine would tear a huge hole through a deer chest cavity but angles and shoulders might be tricky. For a long while a mid-range .357/158 SWC. which matched the woods load for my favorite utility Ruger SA revolver. What I found though was that I seldom carried both the handgun and the carbine and was robbing myself of power if I wanted to carry the handy Marlin for deer or SD, it required a special zero for the mid range loads and did not shoot full power stuff to point of aim.
I finally settled on 158 JHP/.357 full power for the carbine, mainly cause I got a deal on a huge supply of Rem 158' JHP.
Regretfully in the past little bit, my eyes have started to slip and I do not see the front sight on the short little Marlin like I used too. After years of taunting no scopes on traditional levers (and no white line spacers!) I realize that if I want to still fully realize the pontential of the andy Marlin, I may have to scope it, which will degrade its practicality a bit, for me anyhow. That is likely a little ways off, but is probably the future. Until that happens, the Williams peep and factory bead have served me well.
I have carried the Marlin alot of miles on foot, and it rides in the 4WD presently as a truck/utility rifle.
PawPaw has got it, from a carbine tube the .357 gets a big boost over handgun velocities and energies and becomes a serious customer.