patrickd,
Here's a list of things that need to be checked that could very well be causing your problem.
If you are using handloads check the OAL. For SWC ammo I always found 1.245 OAL to work best in most guns and mags. As for JHP the OAL will depend on the shape and length of the bullet. Also inspect the brass for bulges or bad dents that may cause the problem.
If you have not already done so and you are using more than one mag to conduct your test number your mags so you can be sure that it's not just one mag causing the feeding issues. Mags with parallel lips .500 long have more of a tendency to want to nose dive rounds, this takes place most often on the first round being fed from the mag.
Check the feed ramp in the gun for the proper depth and angle. It's not that uncommon to find feed ramps that are short or with incorrect angle even in factory guns. Guns with short feed ramps or incorrect angle will feed ball ammo fine in most cases, but will not feed JHP or SWC ammo reliable.
On guns with the standard 1911 extractor polish and tune the extractor. I like about 20 oz of tension on my extractors.
Check the breech face in the slide. If need be polish and true the breech face.
Barrel timing is another issue that needs to be checked.
What weight recoil spring are you using? Also make sure the recoil spring is installed with the closed end against the recoil shield of the spring guide.
Make sure the bottom of the barrel chamber does not over hang the feed ramp. The proper distance from the feed ramp to bottom of the barrel chamber is .030.
Let us know how everything turns out.
Regards
Bob Hunter
www.huntercustoms.com