Yes
Yes it would get hung up on the slide stop, unless someone depressed the slide release by hand while doing this. The poster didn't say the purpose, but by having the mag in, the mag follower would add a teeny bit of friction upwards on the slide lock lever as the slide rode forward. If the slide doesn't go forward far enough to go into battery due to friction, the gun will not fire. An old recoil spring would perhaps not close the slide completely. Muzzle up to add gravity to the equation. Perhaps a dummy round would add further friction.
You would also know if a recoil spring was old if brass ejection pattern changed and was chucking brass much farther away.
I'm assuming everything is stock parts, and no "work" done on it?
Some folks who installed Apex parts on M&P's (and/or polished the striker block and trigger bar) had timing issues from interference from the striker block not being raised soon enough. Apex worked it out. Some could happen from wear and tear but 2,000 isn't a whole lot unless someone did some work beforehand and put it *almost* out of spec