Hi, Cntryboy,
I actually said that if the jewelling is removed, the bolt will be sloppy. I have had a couple of cases where the customer insisted on jewelling the bolt, and then as soon as wear developed demanded I remove the jewelling and polish the bolt smooth. That will remove enough metal to create play in what was originally a smooth bolt. I agree that the barrel hood area on the 1911 should not contact the slide at all if things are set up right, so that is an area where jewelling should last. But I think you are a bit unrealistic in expecting the user of a bolt rifle to always work the bolt in a perfectly straight line - it don't happen!
Hi, Fremmer,
I have seen wear marks on jewelling done by both gunsmiths and the factory. There are ways of reducing the wear, especially making sure that the inside of the receiver is smooth with no sharp edges, and using a good lubricant. But in most cases it is not really possible to totally eliminate wear on a part that moves inside another part, and any wear on jewelling, IMHO, makes it look worse than no jewelling at all. Let us hear from you after you have used that rifle a bit.
Hi, Dave,
As you say, the original purpose of jewelling was to hold lubricant. So if jewelling is used someplace where there is no contact, it is strictly decorative; if it is used where there is contact and friction, it may serve a purpose but won't be decorative.
Anyway, to each his own.
Jim