My favorite gun in the world is my Ithaca 37 field model. I have many other guns that I love, but I just can't miss with the 37. It ain't beautiful to look at (been around the block a time or two), but put it to your shoulder and swing it, and you will know perfection. If you are built like I am anyway.
Fit and finish on a like new old one is beautiful. I have not seen any of the new production models as of yet, but I would wager that they are better than most for the price.
Mine has never jammed. I do not care to think about how many times I have fired it. I bought it used about 10 years ago.
Find one and put it to your shoulder. You might just like it.