Is this possible?

C

Concerned Citizen

Inactive
A member at another forum posted his collection of Taurus revolvers. As most of you know, what passes for "Stainless Steel" these days is little more then a crappy matte gray finish that almost looks like someone spray painted it on. According to him, this is a newer model gun that used to have one of those crappy matte "stainless" finishes.

If I understood him correctly, he claimed he was able to achieve this by removing the matte gray finish to reveal the real stainless underneath by hand simply using shop rags with Mother's polish and a lot of time and elbow grease. No buffers, machines, etc.

I find it hard to believe he got this gun looking that good only using hand rags and Mother's. When I politely called him out on it, asking him for more details, I never got a reply.

So my question to you is, it is possible to achieve this kind of finish by hand on a modern, mass produced "Matte Stainless" handgun or rifle? If so, why aren't more people doing it?

Rw2hWBv.jpg
 
Last edited:
Mothers mag is some GOOOD stuff, I've never tried polishing stainless steel, but basicly the different stainless finishes are just skin deep.. they're all bare metal and all it takes is polishing to get it shinny like that.. how easy it is I don't know..

But I can tell you raw aluminum, copper, brass, carbon steel, if it's already in good shape you can get that sucker mirror like very quickly with mothers mag and just hand rubbing with a rag.

Like I said never tried to polish stainless but I would not doubt they did it with mothers mag and a rag.
 
Mothers mag is some GOOOD stuff, I've never tried polishing stainless steel, but basicly the different stainless finishes are just skin deep.. they're all bare metal and all it takes is polishing to get it shinny like that.. how easy it is I don't know..

But I can tell you raw aluminum, copper, brass, carbon steel, if it's already in good shape you can get that sucker mirror like very quickly with mothers mag and just hand rubbing with a rag.

Like I said never tried to polish stainless but I would not doubt they did it with mothers mag and a rag.
Click to expand...
The type of stainless I'm talking about is NOT the good kind of stainless, such as the blade of a Victorinox Swiss Army knife. This "stainless" is some kind of dull, matte, powdered coating. This would have to removed in order to get to the real stainless steel underneath. This seems a bit more complex then simply polishing up an existing finish by hand.

I've never attempted to do this only using Mother's and hand rags, but I would like to try it on my Taurus 905 if it were possible to achieve these results.
 
Last edited:
Time and energy is all you need ! Remember that was a 1/3 difference in price between the S&W M27 and M28 .Between matt and polished finish !
 
I used polish with my dremel.

I wonder if I used my tumbler what would happen. I did it to my Taurus Tracker. I hated the Matte finish.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro
 
Be advised that non-stainless steel can be polished up and you will not be able to tell the difference until it rusts. When guns from reputable manufacturers are called Stainless Steel, That piece is Not plated as some here seem to think.

Polished stainless steel finishes are difficult to maintain. The surface scratches very easily compared to hard chrome for instance. The brushed and matte finishes are much preferred by those not inclined to spend time polishing firearms.
 
Last edited:
Still confused on what kind of stainless you are asking about. The brushed finish is not something added to the stainless.
 
If you feel the need to polish a dull stainless firearm and don't have access to a buffing wheel, start with 2000-2500 grit wet/dry sandpaper. This will get you closer to a mirror finish much quicker than just using polish.
 
The mat finish can be achieved with a media blaster, under that is still the metal. It's not changed metal, just finished different. If the you have the time and patience to work in all the nooks and crannies then yes a stainless gun can be made to shine like a mirror.
 
I have actually polished a Taurus revolver(I forget the model number, but it was older, prelock, and looked like the S&W 638). Mothers mag and a rag, plus a good amount of time is all it really takes. If you have deep scratches some wet/dry fine grit sandpaper before the polishing helps. I dont mind the matte or brushed stainless finish unless they get real beat up.
 
The type of stainless I'm talking about is NOT the good kind of stainless, such as the blade of a Victorinox Swiss Army knife.
Click to expand...
There are no "good" or "bad" stainless steels. There just are different types used for different purposes. The stainless steel used in a pocket knife would likely be 440c, a Martinsetic stainless steel. There are three categories of stainless steel, Ferritic, Austenitic, and Martinsetic. Within those three categories of stainless steels, there are more than thirty (as of the 1980's), alloys according to the AISI (American Iron and Steel Insitute). The type of steel used is dictated by what it is going to be used for, via its properties. The finish of a stainless steel, polished or matt, has nothing to do with its composition (or quality) but is purely a matter of aesthetics.
 
"...hated the Matte finish..." Why'd you buy it? Just curious.
"...removing the matte gray finish to reveal the real stainless..." Neither is correct. SS is not shiney until it's polished. There is no such thing as a "real stainless" finish. The metal is SS and isn't a finish.
The unpolished "crappy matte gray finish" is there so sunlight etc. doesn't reflect into your face when shooting outside. It's there for a reason and isn't just decoration or poor QC.
However, any metal can be polished by hand or by using a cloth wheel in a drill press or bench grinder. Best to add some actual metal polish or jeweller's rouge.
 
For the most part the polishing is easy and there are probably dozens of ways to do it. The great thing is if you mess up it is easy to correct. The hard part is getting an even finish on areas that transition from one surface to another like where the barrel threads into the frame. Other than those spots a 10 year old can do it. There's no need to "call someone out". A simple google search will yield 100's of posts and plenty of videos detailing the process.
 
So my question to you is, it is possible to achieve this kind of finish by hand on a modern, mass produced "Matte Stainless" handgun or rifle? If so, why aren't more people doing it?
Click to expand...

Well, I don't do it because I don't like the way it looks. It also removes 100% of the original finish as far as resale is concerned.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top