Improper sized brass

C

Calfpuller

Inactive
I am new to reloading and sized and primed 200 rounds of .223. Proceeded to charge and seat bullets on 100 of these and about 70% of these are hard to get the bolt to close. Should i shoot the hard to close rounds Or will they damage my gun. And how do i resize the other 100 that have been primed safely. All opinions will be helpful. Thanks
 
All of it was once shot brass from multiple companies. And they are lee full length dies. I know how i messed up the sizeing procedure. I just want to know what to do with the finished rounds and primed brass
 
If it's a bolt gun (not a gas gun), go ahead and shoot them. **

For the other cases, simply pull the depriming pin out of the expander
(leaving the expander ball itself) and resize them to spec. For now, do a full
resize by screwing the resizing die in ~1/8 turn past full contact w/ the ram


**If it's a gas gun (e.g., an AR) pull the bullet and resize w/o depriming as suggested above.
 
Yea i messed up I did that with my first 50. But then talked to a family member that told me to back off the die instead...Mistake. Thank you
 
Calfpuller,

A die sizes as follows:

Shoulder%20Setback%20and%20Growth%20II_zpsvgwe5rip.jpg


All these images are relative to the shell holder position, so the shell holder stays put and the die comes down so that you can compare the brass lengths. Notice how, in the first sizing drawing, second from left, the brass, which has been fattened by expanding to fill a chamber, first gets squeezed longer because it gets narrowed first by the die, and that squeezed brass has to go somewhere. When you bring the die down far enough (second sizing step, third from left), it is then that the shoulder is pushed back where it is supposed to be, and the excess brass then flows into the neck. It is that last step that causes you to need to trim brass from time to time. People who use neck sizing only almost never need to trim brass.

Also, in general, once-fired brass is military brass that has often been run through the loose chamber of a fully automatic military weapon. This stuff is often fatter than normal and longer than normal, having been stretched by hard extraction. So there are times when even a properly adjusted standard sizing die can't squeeze them back past their spring threshold. On those occasions, you can use a separate small base die which squeezes them down a bit extra, or you can try sizing the two or three times, letting the brass rest up inside the die for five seconds each time, which often gets another couple of thousandths of shoulder setback. Board member F. Guffey has a simple trick, which is he cuts out a piece of shim stock so it slips between the head of the case and the bottom of its slot in the shell holder. You can usually fit 0.005" shim stock in there, and often something even thicker. By raising the head up in the shell holder, you let the sizing die shorten it that much more during resizing.


As to your current predicament, Mehavey's suggestion is right with most dies, because they mostly have a separate expander ball held in place by a decapping pin chuck. Your Lee, however, has them all as one piece. So if you want to use the Lee die, you will want to remove the decapper/expander rod, size the brass again, perhaps using the shim stock, and afterward put the rod back in place and run the brass up onto the die just far enough to expand the mouth of the case, but not far enough to decap the live primer.

It's a good idea, when manipulating brass with a live primer, to be wearing safety glasses and hearing protection. They can be surprisingly loud and throw a shower of sparks.
 
Last edited:
"...will they damage my gun..." Not unless the powder charge is excessive.
Option one is to shoot 'em assuming you can get the bolt to close. Firing will expand 'em to the chamber dimension and you start over.
Option two is to pull 'em, remove the decapping pin for the die and resize 'em.
Option one would be way better than pulling 200 rounds.
"All of it was once shot brass from multiple companies." Isn't milsurp.
 
By once fired brass i should have clarified that this was ammo I had bought new shot, and then saved the brass to reload. Not milsurp but hunting rounds or fmj's for plinking
 
There are several reasons why they might not chamber:

1. Shoulder not set back far enough.
2. Bullet AOL too long and the bullet is being pushed into the lands of the barrel.

I would smoke some of the bullets, chamber them and see if the lands leave any marks on the bullets.

You should only set the shoulders back a little bit. You can check this be sizing one all of the way down on the shell holder and then seeing if it will chamber. Then back out the die and try another one. You will reach a point where it will not chamber. At that point the die has been backed out too much. Turn back in and try again.
 
By once fired brass i should have clarified that this was ammo I had bought new shot, and then saved the brass to reload. Not milsurp but hunting rounds or fmj's for plinking
Click to expand...

Ok question. Are these rounds fired in the gun that you are loading them for? I.E. you have one bolt rifle, you fired them out of that rifle, and now you are reloading them for that same rifle? If this is the case, and you're full length sizing, then you may not be seating deep enough. Color one with a sharpie, chamber the round, and then extract the round and observe the projectile to see if there's marks were sharpie marker has been rubbed off.

Or your sizing die may not be set correctly. Also check the length of your brass.
 
Easiest approach, which I've done quite a bit over the years, is to buy a Redding Body Die in your caliber and just resize the loaded rounds. The die is inexpensive.

Some years back I sold my Ruger 260 (roomy chamber) and replaced it with a new Tikka with a custom barrel (snug chamber). I had a lot of ammo and didn't want to pull the bullets. I took the Body Die and screwed it down till I reached the shoulders of a loaded round that was raised all the way with the press ram, lowered the ram, screwed the die in a bit, then raised the ram and slightly resized the round. If that didn't allow the round to chamber in the rifle, I screwed the die in a touch more and tried again till I got a round that would chamber. Easy and quick. Did the same with my 223 ammo for this years new barrel.
 
i will look into the body die, overall length on 50 is 2.20 and 2.25 well under the lee dies max length in the directions. I know that i had the dies set wrong now. Just have to undo the damage. Thanks for all the help
 
Calfpuller,

Since the brass came out of your chamber, it is most likely you just got the die out too far and actually lengthened the head to shoulder dimension rather than pushing it back, as my illustration shows. The much less likely possibility is your chamber being extremely off-axis with the bore, so your heads are fire-formed out of square and then don't fit back in when the headstamp isn't oriented the same way it was at the previous firing. To check for this you decap the cases without sizing them, then line them up on a flat surface to see if all the case mouths line up or if they tilt randomly out of line.

The COL is probably OK, but you should check for engraving marks as suggested, just the same. It's how far the bullet ogive is sticking out and not the COL to the nose of the bullet that matters. Below is an illustration of two bullets the exact same distance off the lands, but look how different the COL's are. This is why you want to double-check.

.308%20chamber%203_zps3s1tlcya.gif


The Body Die is a great tool, but unless you get a small base version, it won't necessarily do anything you can't do with your standard die, except that the standard die will resize the neck again when you do it, while the body die will leave the neck alone. If you were going to do this all the time, I'd say getting that die was worth it to extend case life, but I expect you're planning to avoid a repeat of this issue. Where the body die really shines, IMHO, is for use in conjunction with the Lee Collet Die. The latter sizes a neck without any runout. The former handles sizing the body without disturbing the neck. They were made for each other, albeit not intentionally.
 
Check the length of the cases as well. I personally believe that the shoulder being set back to far is not the problem. As you said, you messed up by backing the die out. check the length of the brass before loading and, trim if necessary. God Bless
 
I mentioned the Body Die, and I really do think it's the fastest and easiest way to get from where you are to where you want to be. That said, the first thing I'd do is get a factory round and measure in all directions and compare to your reloads. That's what I finally had to do with my new 223 barrel. No matter WHAT I did, my new loads with new Lapua brass would NOT chamber. Made me crazy. I'm not new at this reloading business, but I had never run into a problem I couldn't solve. Well, I knew the gunsmith had fired factory rounds in it. I had no factory rounds. Haven't shot a factory round this century. Borrowed one from a neighbor. It chambered. I measured it every way possible. It was the case necks not fitting into a tight match chamber. I hadn't asked for that tight a chamber, but that's what I got. The new Lapua brass had relatively thick case neck walls and stretch it with a bullet and it wouldn't fit in the chamber. I turned the necks and all was well, but I finally took it back to the smith to open the chamber to SAAMI specs. Problem solved. Finally.

So measure. Then get the body die and shrink the case just enough.
 
In my experience and laziness as a beginner my handloads of 223 for the AR using once fired brass jammed royally. The once fired brass, bottle neck cases, will grow/lengthen and must be trimmed.
 
Last edited:
The body die only idea is to bump the shoulder back on a loaded cartridge , YES/NO ? You can't do that with any standard FL die . I would not get a body die though . I'd get the Redding type S Full length bushing die . Reason why is if you don't use/put a bushing in the die it works as a body die only . You then will always have the option to buy some bushings and have one of the best FL sizing dies out there .

You will need to remove the decapper/expander rod to use the bushing die as a body die to bump the shoulder of a loaded cartridge .
http://www.midwayusa.com/product/67...-sizer-die-223-remington?cm_vc=ProductFinding

To check for this you decap the cases without sizing them, then line them up on a flat surface to see if all the case mouths line up or if they tilt randomly out of line.
Click to expand...
TOMici.jpg


F. Guffey has a simple trick, which is he cuts out a piece of shim stock so it slips between the head of the case and the bottom of its slot in the shell holder.
k441.jpg
 
Last edited:
Should i shoot the hard to close rounds Or will they damage my gun.
Click to expand...

the reason the rounds are 'hard to close?' could damage your gun. Closing the bolt on ammo that causes difficulty in closing the bolt is a bad habit. When someone tells me they are a reloader then tells me they loaded 100 rounds that will not allow the bolt to close 'I WONDER': How did they get to the status of 'reloader' without knowing if the ammo they are reloading will not allow the bolt to close?

A reloader should be able to determine if the case was sized before they lower the ram. There are times the case has more resistance to sizing than the press can overcome. They have choices, decrease the resistance of the case or increase the presses ability to overcome resistance.

F. Guffey
 
Last edited:
Metal God, the suggestion to buy a Redding Type S FL Bushing Die and then use it without the bushing and other guts is a good one for resizing loaded rounds, but the Body Die is a cheaper way to go, and it will FL resize the case (except for the neck). Depending on the caliber, I have both. For the 260, for instance, I already had a FL Die that I liked, so I wanted to go with the least expensive way to resize the rounds. That was the Body Die.

In some calibers I use the Lee Collet Die (neck size only), so the Body Die is mostly just used to bump the shoulder when needed.

But sometimes other issues arise. I loaded up some 223 rounds the other day, ones where the cases had been sized with the Lee Collet Die. I didn't notice that the Lee Die, needing a bit of lube, had jammed up and rolled the shoulders of some cases slightly, which would now not chamber. I dug out the Body Die, and in just a few minutes had all cases back to 'normal'. So it's good to have one at times. It's cheap, relatively speaking.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top