I would appreciate revolver recommendations for a newbie

Inspectorlee

Inactive
I would like to say hi to everyone on this forum first of all. If my this, my first post, sounds funny or naive, it is because I am not a gun guy (yet!).

I am in the market for a new handgun and am totally clueless as to what to get. Only recently have I fired a handgun. A few months ago, my cousin and I went to the firing range and tried out a Glock and a Sig Sauer. We used up a box of ammo and would switch the guns back after every clip. I was under the impression that both the guns were 9mm's but later found out that they were both .40 semi-autos. The following are details that may affect any recommendations from fellow members:

1. I am 5'6", 130 lbs. Yes, I'm a skinny guy with little hands. I am not weak nor am I super strong. When I fired the two guns, I used a two hand grip. I actually preferred the Sig Sauer because it had more heft to it and that helped with the recoil. I did not attempt to fire the guns with one hand.

2. I have been reading past posts (via the search) in this forum for the past three days but am still confused with some of the acronyms and terms that are commonly thrown around. I am confused when I see sentences such as these: "I would recommend a J frame" or "I prefer the 626 myself." I assume that the J frame is a version of some frame and that a 626 is a model of some manufacturer. But if you respond, please spell out any acronyms or define any terms that you think I wouldn't understand, this would help out a lot.

3. The gun is solely for me. No spouse or secondary user. And if I take it hunting, it would only be twice a year at the most for small game (squirrels and the like). Don't put too much emphasis on the hunting part please.

4. Although I have some basic knowledge of the calibers, I don't know what's the difference between a .38, a .38 special, and a .38 special +P, etc. What is the difference? Also, I know that certain calibers have more recoil than others depending on the amount of gunpowder (180 grain vs. 250 grain) but everything being equal, could someone list the calibers from least recoil to most?

5. I would prefer a six cylinder versus a five cylinder. Also, I have choosen a 4 inch barrel. Am I wrong in my decision's? On a side note, I saw a 6" Raging Bull at a sporting goods store and that thing is HUGE in my opinion. I doubt I could hold it or shoot it.

6. Since I have small hands, should I switch the grips out? Whose should I use? What difference does the material make (wood vs. rubber vs. whatever else is out there)?

7. Although this is highly debated, which manufacturer and what model should I look at (please be specific because I won't know other wise)?

8. If all my questions have already been answered already, kindly point me towards a web page or resource and I won't bother any senior member with further redundant posts. And thank you if you read this far. I truly will appreciate any and all replies in helping me make this choice.

Thank you,
Inspectorlee
 
First off welcome to the forum...youve struck gold. Not with me but with the HUGE amount of absolutely golden information available.....Congrads on your first gun! :D
Answers....
1) Most makers of Revolvers make different frame sizes to accomidate the specific calibers that they are chambered in.
Usually the larger/stronger the round is the larger the frame size.
With S&W the offer many. The farther the letter is down the alph.
the bigger the frame size is. Taurus uses small, med and large for their frame designations.
Example S&W makes a J frame...5 shot small framed revolver.
Its chambered in 32, 38 and 357 Mag. Its a favorite among CCW guys because its small, concealable and packs a pretty mean round. Within these frame sizes are different models of guns.
Usually a different caliber and barrel length. A model 60 is a basic J frame in 38 Spec or 357 mag. A 640 is the same frame and caliber, but has a concealed hammer. The #'s used for models is limitless....given each manufacture has there own model designation.
2)Calibers from "weakest to strongest" and everyone please add and correct me.... :D
32 H&R mag
38 Spec
38 Spec +p
" +P+
44 Spec
45 LC
357 Mag
41 Mag
44 Mag
480 Ruger
454 Casull
3) A great all around gun for a revolver and a beginner is a Ruger GP 100 with a 4" barrel. The gun is chambered for a 357 Mag, but ANY 357 Mag can also shoot 38 Spec. ammo. Start off with this..its much easier on you than the 40 s/autos you started off with. You can work your way up to +P and +P+ 38 Spec loads and them 357 Mag loads. For hunting this gun will work very well also. Lighter/Faster bullets for smaller game and up to 200 gr loads for smaller deer and such.
4) Small hands can be easily fixed with grips...ALOT of grips are made for the Rugers. Wood is nice to shoot with and grips can be found to help with smaller hands if you need it. Rubber is cheaper and helps with recoil much more than the wood does.
Youll just have to check around and see what fits your hands.
Others will have different takes on your questions...Ill bet some will agree with me....I hope :rolleyes:
Shoot well
 
Welcome aboard.

Given the information you have posted, my recommendation would be a used Smith & Wesson Model 13 (blue steel) or 65 (stainless steel). The Model 13/65 is basically the fixed sight Military & Police .38 Special witha 3" to 4" barrel dating back to the turn of the century (1900) - but in .357 caliber. Second choice would be a used Smith & Wesson Model 19 - basically the same gun with adjustable sights and greater variety in barrel length. Both are medium frame (K Frame) - an all around handy size for shooting comfort, fit, finish, control and portability. Any .357 will shoot .38 Special - so might as well get the .357. Power availability with such a revolver will range from pop gun pussy cat to flame throwing hand cannon - in most any bullet configuration you cam imagine.

That said though - I prefer Rugers. Heavier and more durable - and generally less expensive than the Smith & Wessons. Ruger's mid size .357 is the GP 100 that is available in blue or stainless finishes and multiple barrel lengths.

Regarding frame sizes, the Smith & Wesson designations are a pretty good yard stick. The J frames are the smallest, and generally preferred in the concealed .38 Special calibre. They are available in .357 - but are a real handful to control. Range from about 12 to 23 oz. in weight. Up in weight (about 25 oz.) but about the same frame size is Ruger's SP 101 - the smallest .357 I would recommend - similar in durability to the Smith & Wesson K frames. These are all five shots. The K frames (six shot) are medium size frames - a compromise in weight and size to larger frames in .357 caliber (about 30 to 40 ozs.). Originally designed as frequent carry but limited full power shooting pieces. L frames are slightly larger and heavier than the K frames and more durable (Ruger GP 100 and S&W 686). N frames are very large and heavy (.357 & 44 mag). Generally too large for comfortable carry - but will take thousands of full power rounds.

Regarding power levels - the .38 Special is a standard pressure round in that caliber. Pretty mild in most any frame size. .38 +P is about 1/3 to 1/2 between the .38 and .357. Suitable for newer J frames and any K frame. .357 is the same basic diameter as a .38, but a longer case (any .357 chambered revolver can shoot .38 - but not vise versa), and loaded to much higher pressure. Suitable for limited shooting in K frame revolvers, and as much as you want in L or N frame revolvers.

There are also various bullet weights and configurations in the .38/.357 diameter. Generally, heavy, slow and solid is best for target practice - lighter, faster with hollow points is better for personal defence. Again - generally. The really nice thing about the .38/.357 diameter is the variety of bullet configurations and power levels available.

So, back to my original recommendation - a medium frame .357.
 
Inspectorlee!

Welcome to TFL. You have chosen an excellent place to increase your knowledge. Let me make a suggestion. Go to the web sites of gun manufacturers. Here you will find a lot of great information (e.g. what a 686 or 629 or a Blackhawk is) that will stand you in good stead as you learn and make firearm selection choices. FYI I've included some URL's to get you started.

http://www.smith-wesson.com/

http://www.ruger-firearms.com/index.html

http://www.kimberamerica.com/

http://www.sigarms.com/

Hope these help. Good shooting:)
 
...Ruger GP 100 with a 4" barrel. The gun is chambered for a 357 Mag, but ANY 357 Mag can also shoot 38 Spec. ammo. Start off with this.

What Eric said. Yup.
 
A Ruger GP100 or model 19 S&W would both be good starters. They can be used with a wide variety of ammo, and will fit nearly any hand with the right grip . It took me about twenty years and as many guns to learn that. Didn't have places like TFL then. Good luck!
 
What CZ Gunner Said:

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

THIS IS A DUPLICATE THREAD .... ORIGINAL THREAD HAS SEVERAL POSTS.

See: http://www.thefiringline.com/forums...threadid=135008

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++



++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

THIS IS A DUPLICATE THREAD .... ORIGINAL THREAD HAS SEVERAL POSTS.

See: http://www.thefiringline.com/forums...threadid=135008

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++




++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

THIS IS A DUPLICATE THREAD .... ORIGINAL THREAD HAS SEVERAL POSTS.

See: http://www.thefiringline.com/forums...threadid=135008

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++




++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

THIS IS A DUPLICATE THREAD .... ORIGINAL THREAD HAS SEVERAL POSTS.

See: http://www.thefiringline.com/forums...threadid=135008

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++




++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

THIS IS A DUPLICATE THREAD .... ORIGINAL THREAD HAS SEVERAL POSTS.

See: http://www.thefiringline.com/forums...threadid=135008

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++





:o :mad: :eek: :cool: :D :) ;) :rolleyes: :confused: :mad: :barf:
 
Back
Top