Cosmoline: I think I understand your point. That it isn't easy to go into hostil territory and survive. But are you aware that Cooper was hired by at least a few people that live down there that were having real problems with banditos? That he went down there and did the training on site? And at least once or twice the banitos knew he was supposed to be arriving to teach people how to better fight the banditos on their own turf?
Have you read "The Rio Balsas" in Cooper's "Another Country"?
I don't agree with all of Cooper's ideas, but I really do think if you want a gun for anything other than very small game a centerfire makes more sense than a 22rf. A Short light centerfire rifle, doesn't need to be a scout IMO, will do much better for you against goblins or dogs or pigs that you might have trouble with. And you can get them as light as a 22rf rifle. Plus using alex caps you can shoot 22lr hollow points or with aux cartridges you can shoot semi rimmed pistol cartridges with diameters that match bore of rifle [ie 25 acp in 250 savage/257roberts/25-06, 32acp in 308 & 311 rifles, and 38 super in 350 Rem or 358 Norma].
A 257 Roberts from ultralight arms with either Alex Caps or Aux cartridges would give you all the benifits of a 22 rifle IMHO plus allow you the advantages of a centerfire rifle [range and power].
I guess your statement just sounds to close to the "don't resist a goblin" when it attacks because you can get hurt, so you shouldn't carry a gun to fight back with since you might be tempted to use it.
And in getting a degree in Anthropology I met at least one person from SA that was armed & prepared because of Cooper's influence in SA, and saved his own life because of that. I also know of groups of students that went down there unarmed and got raped, because they weren't able to protect themselves from banditos.