DaveMcC, 9mmMike... here's on update:
I successfully modified the cast of my 870P. It's a really good feeling when you can do something yourself! I basically took Dave McC's advise. Here's what I did:
1. Cut up an empty Winchester AA hull into a piece of plastic about 1 inch long and about 1/2 inch wide. Then I folded it in half lengthwise. This resulted in a shim 1 inch by 1/4 inch and about 1/8 - 3/16 in thickness (when fully installed and pressed together).
2. I loosened the stock bolt (but did not remove it).
3. I slid the shim into the left side of the stock, vertically, between the stock bearing plate and the wood stock.
4. Then, making sure it stayed put, I slowly tightened the stock bolt again.
Voila! This resulted in a very nice, secure fit between the stock and receiver. There is a space on the left side that is not flush, but that was to be expected. The resulting cast-off is about a full inch at the end of my recoil pad (R3 pad).
The stock fits me A LOT better now. My eye is directly behind the receiver and the beads line up!
Next step is to adjust the drop. Once I found out how easy it was to adjust the cast, I did experiment and tried adjusting drop the same way using a shim. It worked fairly well, but it took away some of the cast that I added simply because the additional shim on the top of the receiver was further to the right, thus reducing the cast angle.
Next, I need to adust the drop and LOP.
I am planning to get an adjustable butt plate that I can use to increase the drop. Anyone have a recommendation for this? Ideally, I'd like to use my existing Remington R3 recoil pad with it. To adjust LOP (I need to add about a full inch or so), I may be able to use the same adjustable butt plate, or maybe add a spacer between the butt plate and the recoil pad. Recommendations?
That's it! I am a happy camper! I can't wait to try shooting skeet with my newly modified 870.
One other thing... I am considering purchasing a Remington 1100 for skeet also. Does anyone know if the same stock shimming (to adjust cast) will work with an 1100?
Thanks again to Dave McC for his knowledge!
Chris