.9" isn't exactly spread out. However, vertical and horizontal groups can be caused by a host of things. Odd pressure on the rest, too hard a rest, inconsistent trigger control, etc. etc.
And like jwrowland77 says, don't start at the max load or just pick a load and hope. Beginning with the start load and go up by half a grain, then once you have a group, you can go one load back and go up by .1. Mind you, since your AR is shooting .375" groups now you're going to be hard pressed to make that any smaller.