Home Protection/Pistol Set-Up

Sportdog

Moderator
OK, no shoot/don't shoot, no legal ramifications, no personal ramifications, no personal attacks. Strictly a hardware tactical thread please. I have a lot of pistols, both revolvers and semi-auto's. I'm considering setting one up for my bedside personal protection. Since most home invasions happen at night I think, should I consider laser sights, use a flashlight, practice night shooting w/o using the sights at all? What do you guys and gals think. :confused:
 
If it had to be a handgun, I'd want a Glock 45 ACP with a round that wouldn't penetrate too much (walls) with the laser light combo. I'd still prefer a shotgun, but that wasn't your question.
 
Bayou Rifle

I have a couple of shotguns with short barrels but my house is so chopped up I think that I may run into a problem with them so that is why I'm asking about a pistol set-up. I guess though the same question is still out there for me. Flashlight, Lazer light, instinctive point and shoot?
 
I've spent a good deal of time training in low light. Ive also done a good bit of force on force in the dark as well. Heres my thought: In just about any house there is a good amount of ambient light. Electronic devices (clocks, vcr lights, lights from the street etc..) all add some light to a night time living environment. Additionally, your eyes have a great, natural night vision ability after being adjusted to the dark for some time. If you've been asleep for several hours and your awakened by a "bump in the night" your night vision ability will be very good. The bad guy breaking in will not share in that ability to that extent. Hes coming in off the streets (seeing car lights, street lights, and even possibly having just used a flash light to gain access to your home.) Your ability to see in the dark better than the adversary is an advantage you want to exploit. That advantage is lost if you start introducing lights and lasers to the equation. Your best bet would be to know your house. Know where the shadows are, know where the best cover / concealment is. Know where you can and cannot shoot, etc... Then if a home invasion situation should arise, make use of this knowlege. If you use your light, your night vision is largely gone. If you use a laser, your position is compromised to some extent. If you can just run your gun without any addtional light source, thats the best option. Also keep in mind that if there was a break in, your heart is going to be beating out of your chest. Any extra gear that you have to manipulate (lights and lasers) are going to add difficulty to an already stressful situation.

Try this exercise: Set your alarm for 3:30am some saturday morning. Without using any additional lights, try moving through your house and observe what you can and cant see. For myself, in my house, I could easily see if there was somebody there who shouldn't be and could identify whether or not he/she had a weapon. The ambient light coupled with my "night eyes" makes it possible to see what I need to see.

As far as not using your sights: Unless Im shooting from a retention position below my line of sight, I ALWAYS see my front sight. Its just as fast as point shooting. I've proven this to classes time and time and time again. Im a relatively new convert to XS big dot sights. I've found these to be the absolute best, tactical shooting sights on the market. These have worked extremely well for me in all lighting conditions.
 
i perfer a shotgun myself but if you are set on a handgun maybe consider the tauras judge. i stager my rounds starting with bird shot and ending with a larger heavier shot which can also be done with the judge.
 
^ Bird shot is for birds, not people, especially in the wimpy .410......



Me personally, I have a Glock 22 with night-sights on the nightstand loaded with golden sabers...
 
Last edited:
Really, the criteria for a good HD handgun isn't all that different from a good CC handgun. The main difference is that you aren't constrained to what is concealable. I'd say that a full-sized service model (revolver or semi, whatever you're more comfortable with) in .38 Spl +P/9mm and up would be the ideal choice. The one caveat to this is that a 4" barrel revolver or 5" barrel semi would be the longest I'd care for as longer barrels begin to present weapon-retention difficulties in a scuffle. With regards to overpenetration, any handgun round with enough penetration to be suitable for self-defense will also have more than enough penetration to pass through the interior walls of most homes (as will shotgun loaded with birdshot). Personally, I think it's probably wiser to look at overpenetration as a tactics issue rather than an issue of caliber or loading. Try to take a position that minimizes the risk of collateral damage due to overpenetration and then use the most powerful handgun that you can shoot quickly and accurately and load it with premium JHP from a reputable manufacturer.
 
Evan1293: Great post

Good idea about getting up at 3:00am to check out your night vision, etc. It is so much different than when you go to bed and turn out the lights.

My choice for a perfect self defense pistol: Glock 21 (.45acp) with Streamlight tatical light attatched on rail, (my set up). Backed up by a Remington 870 .12 GA (#1 buck) next to my bed.

The Glock 21 works just like a revolver (round is already chambered). Just aim and pull trigger if needed. This is a good choice when using a automatic for self defense, (especially when you have to wake up in the middle of the night in a crisis situaiton).
 
should I consider laser sights, use a flashlight, practice night shooting w/o using the sights at all?

Yes, you should consider all three of those things. Don't just choose one. Learn to shoot with a flashlight, with a laser, and without any artificial aids. Learning to shoot in low light without the artificial aids will help you be even faster and more accurate with the aids - call that the best of both worlds.

My own home defense set up is a laser-equipped handgun stored in a fanny pack along with my cell phone, a spare magazine, and a small but bright tac light. There's also a key to the front door tucked into one of the pockets, attached to an unbroken lumastick.

With this fanny pack set up, I can instantly have everything I need attached to my body, regardless of what I wore (or didn't wear) to bed that night. If I need to move through the house to get one of the children, I won't be juggling these essentials. If I need to stay put, one of the essentials won't end up on the other side of the room from me, leaving me the unsavory choice of doing without or making noise to retrieve it.

The front door key and the lumastick are so that if we decide to hole up and wait for cops, I can throw the key out the window to them when they arrive, and they'll easily spot it.

I've deliberately chosen a handgun rather than a long gun, based mostly on my personal circumstances. The presence of children in the home means I'm more likely to need to move through the home (although I'd much much much rather hole up -- we have to all get together first!). It also means I am more likely to need one hand to hold onto a child or shove the child behind me to safety, leaving only one hand for running the firearm. And my personal tastes are such that I'm much more comfortable with and confident in my handgun use than I am with any long gun, and that's a factor too. Others have different circumstances and different preferences, and that's okay too.

pax
 
Pax

I really like the fanny pack idea with all the things that you may need on your person and the suggested training. Very informative post. Thanks much!
 
Neon

I guess that I should have stated that my pistol of choice will be my Berretta 92FS 9mm 15 shot magazine or my Sig 226 40 S&W 12 shot magazine. I will set one of these up with the lazer sights I think. I seem to shoot the 9mm better and it has more shot capacity but the 40 is more powerfull plus I already have two extra magazines for it. I'm still pondering my choice.:confused:
 
sportdog,

I wouldn't stress to much over it as they are both really nice
guns. If you shoot the Berretta, better than go with that and
use it for HD.

I know the .40 is a better performer than the 9mm but, with
proper ammo this should not be a problem. Making those rounds
hit the target is the most important.
 
Be an extreme snowbird.

Live in the Land of the Midnight Sun (Alaska) during the summer, where you can read a book 24 hours a day without any additional light source, and go visit near the penguins during our winter (same lighting story).

If this is not a realistic option for you, or if you live in either locale year round (or somewhere in-between), it is pretty amazing (noted earlier in thread) just how good your night vision is prior to messing it up with artificial/additional lighting. Very good suggestions above. I will add further to one mentioned, the flashlight.

A really bright flashlight (mine is 120 lumens) flicked on into someone's face for a second when it is dark will effectively "blind" them for a short period of time. Think about after having your picture taken with a flash camera when it is darker; remember seeing those flashes every time that you blink?

The downside is that once you "flash" someone you are now on a timer. (Realize that holding a flashlight that is turned on now makes you a target. And once it goes on and off, they know that you are there.) You might want to do this from cover, and/or be ready to take immediate action.

You can practice "flashing" a "target"/(would not recommend eyes possible damage) in the dark just to get used to the results. There are many different ways to handle "flashlight drills", have fun!

Also consider that any gun mounted light definitely gives someone a return fire vector. (A big "Here I am" target.) Where as a flashlight can be moved around and away from yourself.

Just some thoughts, hope that they help.
 
Pax: Good ideas

Wow, the fanny pack idea is a good one. Think I will try that out to hold all my essential "stuff". Never really thought about the keys,etc.
 
I got a tip from a safety officer at my local range. He said that for fast target acquisition or in dim light, the sights mean nothing. Even in broad daylight, any adrenalin or stress can render your sights usless. There are only two remedies for this. One is you engage in high stress situations and become tolerant of it, or you don't use the sights. The way the guy told me, and it has proved effective, is to use proper gripping techniques on the gun, in which your index finger is parallel to the slide/barrel, and you become conscious of where your finger is pointing and use that to hit your target.

BTW, this is a bit vague, so if you have any questions about the technique, message me.
 
Last edited:
I like to have one pistol set up just for HD. That way I don't have to worry about it and it's independant of my daily CCWs. I know that when I tap the combination into the safe at the side of the bed it will be there. I use a Glock 17 with Cor Bon JHP and a Procyon light / strobe setup. Except for practice sessions it never leaves the safe. 17 +1 means less need for reloading, although I have spares available. I have ammo thats designed to expand big and fragment, less chance of shooting through a target. The WML is backed up by Brite Strike "tactical balls" and a Surefire light so I don't shoot my family by accident.
 
Superhouse 15

You will have to excuse my ignorance but what is "WML" and what are "tactical balls"? I'm almost afraid to ask about that second item. Thanks for enlightening me! (pun intended):)
 
Back
Top