Hogdogs/Tyrajam,
I understand and appreciate your views too, it's nice to have a civil discussion about hunting with dogs ( or anything for that matter!).
Like I said, I never hunted with dogs---almost did once but then decided not to.
I grew up in rural PA in a very small town and as a youngster, about all we had to do was hunt, fish and play sports--so we started hunting pretty early on.
In PA hunting big game with dogs is illegal and IF you see a dog running deer for instance you are permitted to shoot the dog and many hunters will/do.
Some years ago my family and I moved from PA to NC where you are permitted to hunt deer/hogs with dogs.
I was invited to go to a couple of camps and see what was going on and how it was done and I did---I personally didn't care for it---here's why.
I started hunting when I was about 10 years old, if you would have asked me at 20 years of age if I was a "good" hunter I would have said " heck yeah!!" BUT I wasn't. Oh, I harvested game alright but I wasn't a "good" hunter.
I didn't become a good hunter until my 30's and after hunting with a good friend of mine who showed me an awful lot about hunting.
The biggest nicest buck I ever saw taken in PA was shot by my friend at 40 yards --the buck was laying down/hiding in a blow down and I was standing next to him when he shot it and didn't have a clue what the heck he was shooting at!! It was a nice 12 point buck that won all the pools that year and is on my buddies wall right now.
We were "still hunting" and just broke out of some pines ---my friend ALWAYS used binoculars and was glassing the blow downs ahead of us.
All of a sudden, he says don't move, takes his safety off,raises his rifle, and shoots. I'm wondering if he's lost it and ask what the heck he's doing.
He says " got em" and after a short wait, we walk to the blow down, step over some trunks and branches and I about $hit my pants when I see the buck.
Now I understand why he ALWAYS got a nice buck and am kicking myself in the a$$ wondering how many nice buck I walked by in my 1st 20 years of hunting!!
Anyway, I said, " I'll tell everyone you shot him @ 100 yards while he was running "--I was joking--he said " don't say anything but if you do, you tell just the way it happened---thats HUNTING". And it is!!
All of my hunting has been ON FOOT ---in the woods at dark--out at dark--fair hunts--me and the game---and I have humped everything out myself--I have dragged whitetails for HOURS to get them to my truck---all part of hunting---for me.
Learning the habits and haunts of your quarry, making mistakes, learning HOW to hunt, coming home exhausted and empty handed---is hunting for me.
And when your setting in camp around the fire, the stories are more interesting than--" I rode my Honda to the bait , shot the deer, and rode him out"
Your comments about training dogs are very true---I train my Rottweilers---my male will be trailing for his SchH1 soon.
Sorry for the long post.
Dipper