For what it's worth I haven't had much experience with the HKS loaders. I have heard some folks say they're great and others just so-so. I've contemplated purchasing one, but between the loader that came with my Ruger and the Glock loader I bought at a gun show a while back, there haven't been many magazines that have got the best of my thumb. Either way, with the HKS or another, I think you would happy with it....and your thumb will thank you.
Medic
[This message has been edited by Medic (edited February 13, 2000).]