i called Metalife on this today as I am thinking about having a rifle done. The brushed is a satin finish while the matte will be bead blasted. Metalife did a pistol for me a few years ago in the brushed finish and it was really nice. I don't care for the bead blasted look so I'll be going with the brushed finish again. Either should wear well, I would think its just the type of look you prefer.