From long to short (advice for new handgun) ......

bailey bud

New member
I'm a long-time long-gun owner (3 shotguns - 3 rimfire rifles - 2 centerfire).

I've decided to move from long to short (size doesn't matter in my book - I'm over 40).

I'm not really CCW-minded - although I'll likely go to CCW class, primarily to master my weapon. I like to shoot as much as I can - but don't re-load (that might change).

I went to the store the other day - and the dealer said "Hold as many as you can - and buy what feels good in your hands."

So far - the leader is a Colt 1911 Government (upgraded grips - still rosewood, though). It really felt right. I liked the thickness, the weight distribution, and the operation/action.

I thought I was most interested in a Beretta 92FS --- until I held it (way too bulky). Not very keen on the lack of safety for the S&W Sigma (price is fantastic). Mildly curious with the 24/7 Pro (great price at Buds Gun shop). I keep thinking that an XD or 24/7 OSS might be interesting (didn't like the safety on the XD - haven't tried the OSS).

I don't see myself joining the glock cult (still not convinced that composite is worth the price).

I'm not in a hurry - and have sworn not to buy anything I haven't held at least once. (try out at the dealer - buy at Buds - unless the dealer has a killer price --- thank the dealer by buying ammo there).

Any suggestions of other handguns to consider?

The only non-semi-auto that I'd consider would be a Dan Wesson Pistol Pack. (collectible value, as well as practical use).
 
Last edited:
Do you plan on considering primarily automatics? Following the "try by feel" route, I think the most comfortable handgun is a 4" S&W model 686 revolver dressed with Hogue rubber grips. I do agree that the 1911 is nice in the hand; my favorite grips are the Pachmayr American Legends.
 
1911 is a great way to go but I've never met anyone that was happy with a S&W sigma the triggers are horrible
 
Others to consider:
9mm---
1. 1911 S&W
2. HK P30s, P2000
3. Sig P22x
4. Walther P99
357/38---
5. S&W 586/686 (no lock) 4" or 6".
22LR
1. Ruger MKxxxx
2. Ruger 22/45
3. Browning Buckmark
 
Back
Top