Firearms in cabins -- re the two escapees

W

willr

New member
We've understood from news reports that the two escapees in NY obtained firearms from unoccupied cabins in the forest. Having owned a cabin in a National Forest some years ago, it is beyond my understanding that anyone would leave firearms in an unoccupied cabin. Of course, we were broken into several times while we owned it. Hence learned not to leave anything of value there while we were gone. Can anyone justify what happened in NY?
willr
 
It's understandable for folks to leave things in their hunting or retreat cabins.
Maybe to have a spare weapon during hunting season for guests, or as a backup in case their main gun becomes disabled.
Or to have a weapon in place in case of emergency.
Obviously not the best of ideas in this instance.
Having them locked up and hidden would have been better, though.
 
My gal and I were talking about this yesterday, and both of us found it astonishing that someone would be so irresponsible as to leave guns in a cabin in the woods like that. Ammo, maybe, but the guns themselves? It's practically asking for trouble.
 
We have a family cabin in the woods

While we don't leave firearms in it(there have been a few break ins over the years)how is it my responsibility to keep other people from stealing my property?
 
"how is it my responsibility to keep others from stealing your property"

I think what you're getting at is that a thief or robber is the one to blame, as they are the ones who went out of their way to commit a crime. Yes, you're correct. You are not a criminal's parent or guardian and shouldn't be held responsible for their actions unless you knowingly aid someone commit a crime.

But if you take your statement literally, it's always been our responsibility, or choice. If you don't want your property stolen. I mean, no one else would do that for you. If you don't care that much, you don't have to lock things away. If you hire a company to provide security for your house it becomes their responsibility... but you're still showing you are being responsible by hiring them. I bet you lock your doors, so I don't think that's what you meant :) Anything else you do on top is out of being considerate and gracious. Wouldn't want to tempt others from doing something even if they *know* they're not supposed to.

At the same time we do see people held responsible for others' actions. Doctors get bad reputations because some patients lie then abuse/sell the narcotics they are prescribed. Luckygunner was sued (it failed) because someone wanted to blame them for selling ammo to a future mass shooter.
 
Last edited:
how is it my responsibility to keep other people from stealing my property?
Click to expand...

It's not. I agree with you on that. However, studying human behavior for 58 years has taught me that many people cannot be trusted to respect my property. It follows that I have a responsibility to not make theft of my property easy for them, or something I might regret if a weapon falls into the wrong hands.
 
I guess it's just as irresponsible to go out shopping for the day and leave your guns in your house, waiting to be stolen.

Or park your car in your driveway at night, instead of in the garage.

Or carry more than one credit card or a blank check in your wallet, just in case you need them.
 
I'm with those that see nothing wrong with keeping a firearm stored in a cabin that they own on their land that they pay taxes on. I'm assuming that the cabin itself can be locked up somehow. How is this different than keeping a firearm at hidden away at my home when I go on vacation? Are we going to mandate that EVERYONE who owns a firearm must have a gun safe with a rating of XYZ?

Because, that's what folks are really saying.
 
Last edited:
If I was fortunate to own a vacation home, I would likely keep a couple arms there, just in case something happened to my main residence. But, they would be hidden in a false stair or shelf or something similar. Lots of cool options for hiding guns, especially in a wood cabin.

Your house could just as likely get broken into as a rarely used cabin, so I don't see why there would be an exclusion to keeping firearms there.
 
I don't pack up and take my guns with me when I leave the house for a few hours or go on vacations for a few days. There is nothing irresponsible about it. The bad guys broke in and stole from legal gun owners. Lets remember who the criminals are here.
 
Everyone seems to be assuming this gun or guns WEREN'T locked up or hidden.
They broke out of a max security prison, so locks don't slow them down much
 
but the guns themselves? It's practically asking for trouble.
Click to expand...

Why is it asking for trouble? If you keep a gun in your car, is that asking for trouble as well? Does that mean that cops or bad guys have some super power to detect it?

Maybe some of those folks live in an urban area where having their hunting guns inside the city limits poses more hassle to them than leaving in the cabin......

You're asking for more trouble from bears by leaving peanut butter in there - which from the articles - seems to be a common thing to do.
 
Good point snyper !
Times have changed .People's respect for property has changed . Crime induced by drugs are common now. In that part of NY State it was always hard to get to ,without the vehicles and highways which are common now.
 
We have a hunting cabin in the woods with a couple of old .22s and a shotgun.

I can think of at least 2 other vacation homes around here with firearms and no permanent occupants.

Id say its more the norm than an anomaly.
 
Back in the day that I grew up in, having guns in your cabin was no different than having other tools there. Yes, they'd probably put out of sight but not secured. But just like having a gun display cabinet, you can't do that anymore.
 
Why is it asking for trouble?
Click to expand...

Because most people return to their home or car on a frequent basis, and they are more apt to be located in areas where they are watched more closely.
A cabin in the woods is secluded, and might not be visited for weeks or months at a time.

Camps around here suffer from break-ins at a high rate, while home burglaries are relatively rare. That's why I would never leave a gun in a camp, based on that knowledge.
 
barn gun

A "barn gun" is a pretty common thing out in the country. So to a "truck gun". I suppose there could be such a thing as a "cabin gun". I have a .410 shotgun hidden near the back door, where it has dispatched quite a few snakes on and around our place.

Long term absence....I lock'em all up. And I'm opposed to "storing" a PD handgun in an unattended car.

Murphy says when you really need it, it'll still be in the glove box.
 
We never leave firearms or alcohol at our hunting camp. Camp is built of stone, with steel shutters on windows and doors, but thieves have been creative in breaking in-once attaching a chain to the door steel shutter and pulling it open, another time, using a chain saw to cut through a section of roof to get inside.

We're to the point, that we may just leave the door open, with a note, to prevent the damage. Nothing of real value inside.
 
Lets say you do leave a firearm in a cabin, or at home, for that matter. Wouldnt you try to place it in secure not-so-obvious place? All the firearms in my household are placed in locked containers and in places which are not obvious. So for a cabin, I can imagine the floor or the ceiling might be a good location. A cabin has a lot of places where something could be hidden easily.

In any event, I would not leave firearms in a temporary or seasonal place of occupation. That makes absolutely no sense and its irresponsible. At the very least, if you do leave a firearm in the cabin, you can at least not leave ammo or disassemble the firearm placing the parts in two different areas of the cabin. etc...
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top