I purchased an American Classic Commander in 9mm, blued, back in September. It shoots incredibly great, but the ejector broke the front peg broke flush with the frame somehow. The smith at the service center said he'd never seen that happen before on any pistol. So they replaced the whole thing. I chalk that up to just being a bad part, 100 to 1 shot. The replacement arrived quickly, is of just as good quality (sans ejector issue) and shoots great.
I think I paid around $500. Very impressed with it. The only caveat is its all steel, not alloy framed like you're looking for.