Conventional vs Stainless Barrels

R&H

New member
I was under the impression that stainless steel barrels last longer than conventional barrels. I was wondering if this is true and if so roughly how much longer? I have also heard that conventional barrel are also harder and therefore harder to dammage during cleaning and such, and that the SS barrels last longer because the SS is less reactive and takes longer to burn out. Is this true also?

I am aware that SS is less likely to rust but I really don't care. I live in UTAH and as long as I don't hose my gun down with salt water and stick it under my bed rust isn't a problem.
 
You have got it backwards. The SS barrels don't last as long as the chrome moly barrels. However, the SS barrels are more accurate, and of course, more expensive.
 
I asked my gunsmith. He said that the use of aluminum in SS barrels makes them react more to heat. He claims carbon steel barrels are still the most accurate, though improvements in stainless are making it harder to tell a difference.
 
Wrongo - If CM steel was the most accurate, don't you think that folks like Tony Boyer would be shooting it?

Most, if not all, of the competition BR rifles I've seen have stainless barrels. They clean easier than CM, they don't wear as fast (an extra 200-300 rounds of useful life), and while they're harder to machine (which is why some gunsmiths bitch about 'em), they're the best choice...
 
Unless there's some new breakthroughs I'm unaware of stainless steel doesn't contain aluminum, nickel and chromium are the major alloying metals. Blued steel barrels are made from various alloys of ferrous steel, generically called "carbon" steel, "chrome moly" or simply "moly" steel because of the alloying elements.

A chrome lined barrel is different, it's essentially a very thin layer of pure chrome that's plated to the inside of the barrel after it's made, with rare exceptions this is only done to military rifles. Military barrels are chromed for a number of reasons, barrel life being one of them but more precisely to protect the barrel from damage during cleaning. Anyone who's done a hitch can tell ya how often military rifles are cleaned and the effort expended getting the bores beyond spotless. This constant over-cleaning combined with Uncle Sam's POS jointed cleaning rods has ruined more barrels than any other single cause.

A stainless barrel will last longer. Exactly how long is hard to say but some of the number I've heard from Service Rifle shooters is a conventional barrel might be good for 5 thousand rounds, stainless for 6 maybe 7. Chrome lined barrels will last about as long as stainless but aren't used for competition shooting because they are typically less accurate and no civilian makers offer chrome lined barrels. And though stainless barrels have a longer life, because they can better tolerate high flame temperatures, they are more easily damaged because they are not as hard as blue steeled barrels and therefore more readily damaged due to improper cleaning. -- Kernel
 
Back
Top