Compact 1911 vs Compact 1911. Which is better?

[Lightsped]

I am considering buying either a Springfield Ultra Carry V-10 3.5 inch barrel, or a Kimber Ultra Carry with the 3 inch barrel.

Which gun is superior in terms of fit, finish, durablilty, and accuracy?

 

[SgtGunner]

I got the V10 Loaded Ultra Compact in feb. Absolutely love this gun. Actually just had a trigger job done to take akk the creep outta the trigger. Is amazing now. Now for new grips and all is good.

I wouldnt give up my V10 for any amount of money.

 

[Ewok_Guy]

Both are the finest compact 1911s on the market today.
You simply cannot go wrong with either.

 

[blades67]

Get both!

If the price is the same, or at least close enough that you don't care, then get the one that feels the best to you. The Springfield 1911 line feels different than most other manufacturers, some like it better, some can't stand it.

 

[SA Scott]

Having owned a V-10 and lusted after an Ultra Carry, I would say that accuracy is comparable. You'll have to choose based on fit & finish vs. durability.

The surfaces on the Kimber are more user-friendly, smooth and snag-free. I shot IDPA with the V-10 and came away with bloodied hands from sharp edges more than once. There were also visible irregularities on the frame of my V-10.

However, I've also seen chewed-up feed ramps on an Ultra Carry and Stainless Covert. Not a problem for the integral ramp on the V-10. The Springfields seem built to take more abuse.

Both manufacturers have addressed some of the issues I've referred to. I think you can make either pistol your own. You may not be able to do it out of the box.

SA Scott

P.S. I like Para-Ordnance pistols, so go figure.

 

[VVG]

If you're not going to consider the SIG P245, why, it doesn't matter!

 

[Kermit]

Get the no compensated gun! I was shooting w/ a buddy that owns the V-12 and I was allowed to shoot a few rounds from it. I really didn't like the debris spray or flash it generated. If this gun is going to be used as a self defense gun, these things have to be considered.

 

[OTISZ]

Try firing a ported auto in low or no light situations. Your night vision is gone after first shot and you night sites are useless. I do not like ported autos. It is an answer to a problem that isn't there. Just my $.02.