Colt & Remington Pistols - Can someone help?

S

SD Armory

Inactive
I have an opportunity to purchase these two revolvers and I would like to get some advise. Basically, if they are real or replicas?

In the pictures of both revolvers, the Remington is on top.

Serial #s on the Colt are 86833. From the googling I did, I cannot find a reference to any #s near these. The cylinder is also marked Colt Patent No 833...again no luck on google.

The Remington looks to be a 1857 model from the pictures i could find.

Any and all help is very appreciated.

More pics to follow...
 

Attachments

  • both2.jpg
    both2.jpg
    231.6 KB · Views: 102
  • both1.jpg
    both1.jpg
    235.8 KB · Views: 76
  • colt1.jpg
    colt1.jpg
    229.2 KB · Views: 72
Last of the pics.

Also, if there are any markings or specifics I should look for to confirm the identification of either revolver, please let me know. These are the only pictures I have for now.
 

Attachments

  • rem2.jpg
    rem2.jpg
    233.4 KB · Views: 54
  • rem3.jpg
    rem3.jpg
    235.4 KB · Views: 46
pohill - Best pics I have at the moment. Thanks for your insight. So would you think at least the Colt is not a replica?
 
It's tough to say for sure. Based on the serial number alone, I'd say it was original, but there are many fakes out there. The bluing looks too good to be real old, but that could be the clarity of the pic, or it could have been reblued, or it could be a pristine original. I don't see a cylinder scene, so it might have worn off before the reblue. The lettering looks almost too clear. Do you see any other markings on the side of the frame?
Like I said, if you can get some brighter pics...
 
I have an original 1851 .36 that was most likely reblued a long time ago. The rebluing might have taken away from the value but, in my mind, it was a good thing because it preserved the gun (it's a shooter). I recently bought an H.Aston .54 caliber that was a real mess. I cleaned it up and actually increased its value.
I've heard both sides of the refinishing argument and most experts say to leave it as it is, and not refinish it. Tough call.
 
Yeah, a lot of people never figure that out. I've seen a lot of old Colt's being tauted as a matching numbers gun with the wrong cylinder' It should read
Colt's patent
No. 833
 
I'm by no means an expert but I've never seen one or a pic of one that just said Colt patent, they all said Colts. The Colt patent no 833 is very sharp and pristine looking for it to not have any cylinder scene left. I haven't handled a second or third gen so I don't know how they're marked. Maybe somebody did some work on the numbers and is trying to pass them off as originals. Go to some of the auction sites and look at some original guns. Gunbroker or Gunsamerica will have guns up with lots of closeup pics. Look at some of them and compare them to yours.
 
Colt looks like it could be a tired old original that has been heavily worked on. It has been refinished - the frame should be case hardened - and the lettering and numbers have been mostly redone (not very well either).

Frontier
 
definitely redone, and the cylinder is faked. The wording is wrong as is the shape of the letters and numbers. Plus as aothers have noted, the lack of a scene with such clear lettering is just not right. The guns were all numbered at the time of assembly--and hand stamped with the assembler's personal set of dies. The numbers should therefore always match, except in the rare case of an overstrike where he picked up the wrong tool.
Go to Gutterman's Historical Weapons if you want to see some real antiques in unrefinished condition. And look at the prices there also.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top