Colt Model 1917 Question

S

Sagebrush

Inactive
I posted this in another forum, but perhaps this is the better place for it. I ask your forebearance because I'm new to this place.

Anyhow, here's my query. I am interested in a Model 1917 marked US Army that is either chrome or nickel. Were any of the Army models originally plated? If not, how much, in general, would the gun having been refinished like that hurt its value? Would it just be a curio/shooter?
 
In my opinion, that is a refinish. It depends on the condition still. I would guess the refinish LESSENS the value by $135.00 to $300.00. Markings may have been removed, tolerances may have been changed and screws may have been damaged. I saw a poor "bubbly nickel 1917 recently for $385.00, I passed.
 
The Colt 1917 revolver was only made in 1917 and 1918, during the war.

These were an "expedient" firearm used to fill the demand for pistols, when enough 1911 autos couldn't be supplied.

These were all produced under government contract for military use. As such, NO Colt or S&W Model 1917 revolvers were nickel plated by the factories.

It's not uncommon to find these older revolvers with re-blue or nickel finishes.
Refinishing, especially in nickel reduces value considerably.
 
Thanks for the information. I appreciate your sharing your knowledge. I think I'll pass on the Colt.

I'm pleased with my last purchase, though. A couple of weeks ago I bought a S&W Model 627 5" Performance Center Model at a good price. It was one of the first run so it wasn't shipped with the pretty aluminum case. But it also doesn't have the key lock mechanism, either. It's a beautiful revolver. And shoots nice, too.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top