Comparing ballistics of different manufacturers, S&B .40S&W and.45ACP pretty much run with the packs. The 9mm is a hair hotter than the competition at 1280ft/sec and 423 ft/lbs at the muzzle (pretty close to +P rating).
Their 158 grain .357 runs in at 1394ft/sec and 687 ft/lbs, at the muzzle, which is quite a bit 'hotter' than American Eagle, UMC, and Speer Lawman. I shoot quite a bit of it myself. Have never had a problem with extraction EXCEPT for when I shot the magnums after .38spls. The .38s are a shorter casing and allow the chambers to foul between the .38 casing and the .357 seat. When a magnum in then inserted, fired and expanded they are a real delight to get out of the cylinder. When I was new to the magnums, I assumed it was case expansion. What it is, is case expansion in a partially fouled chamber. This may be your problem. Incidentally, I have use the .357 S&Bs in a Smith 686, Smith model 60 and a Ruger GP141, all without a single problem. Every round has fired the first time and extracted properly (unless .38s were fired first).