Do you have to use a case gage when loading rifle.
If the ‘you’ in your question is me the answer is no. If your question has something to do with my opinion about the use of the case gage then the answer is yes; I recommend the Wilson case gage.
I am the fan of measuring before and again after. It is possible for a reloader to determine the effect the chamber had on the case when fired ‘IF!’ (BIG IF) the reloader/shooter measured the length of the case from the shoulder to the case head before firing.
Next step after firing; after measuring the length of the case from the shoulder to the case head the reloader can measure the length of the case from the shoulder to the case head after sizing.
And then? There is the ‘before that’. A reloader should understand the meaning of minimum length
Full length sized. A reloader should understand the meaning of a go-gage length chamber and a no-go gage length chamber; after that understanding what is meant by field reject length should be easier.
From the beginning the Wilson case gage was designed to be used with a straight edge; the problem? Using the straight edge was optional. Reminds me of a book written by Melville about a big whale; in the book there is a line that goes something like ‘ all Save one’. For me it was a simple progression when using the straight edge, I added the feeler gage to measure the gap between the gage and straight edge. I know that makes no sense to anyone but if the reloader understood the Wilson case gage has two steps/heights, one is minimum length and the other is go-gage length. When I use the feeler gage I add the thickness of the gage to the go-gage length of the gage.
The Wilson case gage is a datum based tool. The datum in the Wilson case gage has a radius. The radius makes the datum case friendly. I make datums, my datums are not case friendly because I can use them to scribe the case.
Back to “Do you have to use…”. No I use barrel stubs, take off barrels, worn out barrels and new barrels. Problem; It is not likely I am going to be able to check the length of a fired case in one of the options above. The advantage goes the Wilson case gage because it is cut to check fired and sized cases. Then there is the jump to the conclusion the Wilson case gage can not measure the diameter of the case. The Wilson case gage instructions were printed in about 1955; the instructions included the part about the straight edge. Point; in 60 years reloaders are still using their thumb nail to check case protrusion above the gage.
F. Guffey