Buck and Ball shotguns....

Dave McC

Staff In Memoriam
Had an inquiry about these, so....

In the 1800s, many Europeans spent time in wild places from the Punjab to Australia to South America to Africa. Ofen times, these places called for a variety of firearms missions, from sport to food to defense to "sorting out" some maneating or killing critter who was taking locals off the count.

One approach to a utility firearm back then consisted of a doubled bbled SXS gun with shallow rifling in one bbl near the muzzle, and one bbl with none but often choked a bit.Often these were called Paradox or Cape guns. A slug or round ball was used in the rifled bbl and varied shot loads, including buckshot, in the other. Often flip up, Express style sights,sling swivels, and other accessories were installed to aid performance. The fact that this was a good idea can be observed in that most of the surviving Paradoxes show lots of wear. A number of them also have the rifling bored out, meaning that the shotgun segment of their use became more important when smokeless powder and magazine rifles had widespread distribution. But, until that day, a weapon that was as versatile and powerful as a modern day pumpgun was a popular choice.

Since this weapon was meant to deal with large, bellicose critters at close range, bores were on the large side, with 12, 10 and 8 gauges being popular. One 8 bore load, IIRC, was a 2 1/4 oz lead slug similar to the Minie ball of Civil War fame pushed by 110 gr of coarse black powder.Yes, they were real men then(G)...

The weapons themselves ran a bit heavier than pure shotguns of the time, partly because they needed to be rugged and partly because the extra weight soaked up the kick from heavy loads. Firms up to H&H and Sauer made them, with a lot of midgrade makers like Army and Navy, W and C Scott, etc, making these for civil servants and explorers rather than the gentry.

Here in the US, the idea never caught on like it did overseas, tho I've seen a Parker 10 used for deer hunting in the South set up with sights and used for buck and ball. And a slightly demented gun smith of my acquaintance long ago used a cut down 10 ga Greener with BP loads as his do all gun. And I've seen a few others here and there, but neither seen them shot or shot them.I've even seen one that had the choke portion near the muzzle rifled with shallow,slow twist rifling to imitate the old Paradox style bore.The owner used a round ball handload and claimed good performance on whitetails.

So what pertinence does this have in this age of repeaters and dedicated slug shooters?

Many of us have older doubles of no great collector value,maybe a Savage 311, a Stevens or Iver Johnson, that could see a new day as a buck and ball gun. Most States in the South allow both slugs and buck for deer, and we all want the most versatility out of at least one shotgun, right?

Few old doubles shoot slugs to the same place from both bbls. One bbl will oft do well grouping slugs where they should be at moderate range, and often also to POA. A little benchtesting and R&D should come up with a bucknball combination that'll be a pure D buttkicker in their shotgun.

And, this could be a nice use for those CAS style doubles,or maybe a Lupara style, as someone wrote recently about.

A caution, get a good smith's opinion on using slugs in any old shotgun, and he/she should go over the gun also.

With the smith's blessing, you may have a good project for getting through this too late to hunt, too early to fish season and an antidote for cabin fever...
 
buck and ball

What you describe dave, is what I long considered the Ultimate survivial/defensive weapon :)

I know a lot of folks would say the pump and it's ability to hold alot of rounds is what we need when TSHTF, but I think a very versatile double like you describe is what I want.

It would need double triggers so barrel selection could be instantaneous,and with Brenneke slugs and birdshot you could be ready for most any type game. I think some European gunmakers still produce something similar , though I haven't found one yet.

If you start such a project please keep us informed,For now I've been fooling with different loads for my BSS trying to get decent results with buck&ball just useing the front bead,I may try adding a second bead to aid in slug shooting but right now I'm just playing.
 
You've made some good points,Huntsman. Here's a couple more.

Many SXS's are choked IC and Modified. Oft the IC bbl's the best choice for slugs, and Modified usually works with buck. For those guns choked tighter, opening the mod bbl to Cylinder or IC will cover the gamut of game gathering, WIHTF, and do a yeoman job at defense,

While the repeaters have more shots on call, no repeater surpasses the double in speed for getting off those two.

A well made SXS with two triggers comes close to being an immortal gun and works with a variety of ammo. And, the front trigger usually works the open bbl, so the sequence can be slug, buck,etc. IOW, an aimed first shot to place the slug, then a followup insurance shot of buck. Or, depending on circumstance, two loads of buck or birdshot.

Most SXS I've tried with slugs and a bead will do OK up to 50 yards. Adding a second bead may either extend that slightly or tighten up those 50 yard groups. I've toyed with the idea of a folding tang sight for slug shooting on one of these, but haven't tried it yet.

Unfortunately, finances at present dictate no new projects, and first up would be Frankenstein II, a built at home 870. Maybe after that, or if I run across a beater double at a great price.

The "Ranger" I built as a Lupara would probably do well at this, but the relative that has it now would let his first born child go before he gives that one up.....
 
Sidebar to a great post by Dave.

If one has two rounds between the fingers of the non trigger hand, a double with ejectors can get four rounds off extremely quickly.....with a bit of practice of course.

Sam
 
Whats a Lupara? I vaguely remember it as being some type of shotguns used by the Mafia, but other than that I'm clueless.

Kharn
 
LUPARA

I don't know where he got the info, but I learned about Lupara from the writings of Jeff Cooper, particularly in "To Ride, Shoot Straight and Tell the Truth" (Paladin Press).

The term describes short barreled double shotguns, apparently twelve guage, traditionally with exposed hammers and a sling, used in Silicy (maybe Italy too) as fighting shotguns. Watch "The Godfather" for some good scenes of Michael Corleone's bodyguards carrying Lupara, with shells in a leather belt with open top shell pouches (or maybe loops).

They appeal to me as a home defense gun because they can be kept loaded without having to be cocked and reliant on a tang safety.
 
I guess the spendy solution is to get a drilling, the one I'm partial too is SxS 12 with .30-06 under. Slug, buckshot, ballistic tip, that should just about cover all the bases. As I stand to inherit some of these, I hope I don't get one soon.
 
I learned about Luparas at my Grandma's knee literally. Her maiden name was Papania, and her oldest sister was born in Termini,Sicily. She wore black from the day her husband died to the day she did, 1965 to 88. She described her father's Lupara, and how he used it to defend his store in Bloomsburg, Pa, in the early 1900s. She also had his handgun, a top break 32 of uncertain brand, but with the nickel plating and MOP grips so popular for dress wear then.

Luparas are Italian, but the bloodiest part of Italy is Sicily. And those shotguns are GP tools, oft used to hunt rabbits, birds etc.

Joe, Drillings and other combo guns are another approach, and one with some merit. Commonly in Europe, it's two 16 gauge bbls with a military caliber like 7X57mm, etc, or a stopper caliber like 9.3X64mm. Boar hunters, I understand, tend to use the shotgun bbls and Brennekes.These tend to be heavy but not really untotable.
 
Oh I know, one of the trio is 12's over 9.3x64. Now that's a weird combo! The one that gets used from birds to bear is shorter, 20" barrels and only 7 lbs sporting a Leoupold. Is Lupara just Italian for coach gun or is there a difference?
 
My references and observations show the Cape Gun and the Paradox as separate designs.

The few Paradoxes (also WR Exploras and Faunettas, and C&H Collindians and Lancaster oval bores, and Greener Invisible Rifling, etc. because Paradox was a H&H trademark and their particular ratchet style rifling was patent by Col Fosberry) that I have seen were muzzle rifled in both barrels. They were in stores and gun shows so I didn't get to shoot them but they were supposedly regulated for bullets and said to give about improved cylinder with shot.

The Cape Gun is a SXS with one shot barrel and one conventional rifle barrel. Greener says a 16 ga X .450 No 2 was common in Cape Colony.

There are also otherwise ordinary shotguns with folding sights and barrels regulated for Brennekes. You can still get one from Chapuis.

A friend of mine wanted to play safari and we shot some sabot slugs from his SKB without much accuracy and no regulation. So he bought a .450 BPE, but the shotgun would have been handy if set up for ball.

Drillings I have seen are more common in 9.3 x 74R than the rimless 9.3x64 Brenneke round. Many old ones are 9.3 x 72R, which sounds similar but is much less powerful.
 
I believe Lupara comes from Lupo, wolf, but have no backup info on it.20" bbls is rather short for a Drilling, most have 24-26" bbls that I've seen.
And they run heavy. 3 bbls worth of metal will do that.

Jim, I defer to your superior knowledge. I grew up near a drilling with a 9.3X64 bbl, a duffel gun brought back by a friend of Pop's and my asst Scoutmaster. He used it for whitetail and we hunted with him for years.

However, I see a recent article on Sauer guns in Shooting Sportsman has the 74R cartridge being used for the Drillings made for the Luftwaffe, the most common model of same now found, I think.

I think Cape Gun and Paradox have been misused widely and oft generically. You're right about the makers.I've seen shotguns with sights labeled Cape Guns, and some with rifling in one bbl called paradoxes that certainly weren't H&H.

And a slug gun, set up with sights and bbls regulated for Brennekes, would fit my parameters for a brush gun for deer and hogs. It'd be close to optimum, in fact.
 
Back
Top