Try calling shortly after they open - 9:00 AM your time.
Boyds has a pretty good reputation for handling defects, customer complaints, and billing/shipping issues. Try calling at a different time, and see if they'll get everything sorted to your satisfaction.
But, they do anger a few customers, once in a while.
I'm one of them. Almost six ago, I ordered a limited production stock that was on sale. It turned out to be the last one in stock. When it arrived (on a Friday), I discovered that the inletting and barrel channel had been milled off center and canted to the left, and the stock itself was warped. It was majorly defective - not even something that they would sell as a factory second.
Monday was Memorial Day, which meant that I had to wait until Tuesday to call them.
When I got ahold of them, the conversation went south very quickly.
The basic premise of the conversation was that I was shipped the wrong and/or defective product. But, since they had nothing to ship me as a replacement, they seemed to get completely stupid. Even the supposed 'supervisor' gave me the same moronic lines.
They started quoting a "72 hour" limit on 'wrong product' complaints, even though they have a 90 day return policy. When I pointed out the idiocy of those statements, with a late Friday delivery and a holiday weekend in play, they then turned to "no refunds or returns on factory seconds."
Umm.... Yea... I didn't order a factory second!
Long, increasingly frustrating story short... They told me that I could pay for shipping and return it,
plus a restocking fee would be withheld from the refund. If that wasn't satisfactory, they pretty much recommended I 'eat poop' - there was nothing else that they were willing to do for me.
Having purchased the stock with a debit card, not a credit card, through a bank that wouldn't charge-back anything firearm related, I was stuck with it.
I eventually managed to sell the stock to someone that was desparate to get their hands on that model - even a defective example - and made back about 60% of my money. But the experience really left a bad taste in my mouth....