Maalox Alert - Cynthia is at it again.
So much for the "he killed by accident" tactic.
http://web.philly.com/content/inquirer/2000/06/05/opinion/TUCKER05.htm
Commentary / Cynthia Tucker
Boy who killed his teacher is reflection of our culture
By Cynthia Tucker
'Just watch. I'll be all over the news."
Thirteen-year-old Nathaniel Brazill reportedly gave that warning to a classmate hours before he took a .25-caliber semiautomatic pistol to school and shot a teacher to death on May 26. His utterance, if true, may give us more insight into Nathaniel's horrendous act than anything we are likely to hear about his family, his grades or his ambitions.
In a society that values celebrity more than honor, notoriety more than accomplishment, young Nathaniel had learned that committing a horrible crime could gain him instant and widespread recognition. His status on the honor roll couldn't do that. Nor could his perfect attendance record. But shooting Barry Grunow, a beloved English teacher at Nathaniel's Palm Beach County, Fla., middle school, could and did.
"This is a tragedy," said Nathaniel Brazill Sr. "I am so sorry for the family of this teacher - so sorry." Neither months of counseling nor years of pondering are ever likely to yield any more clues to Nathaniel's crime. He is, after all, just a child - impulsive, easily swayed, eager to impress his pals, blissfully ignorant of long-term consequences. And children, especially adolescents, can be so difficult to decipher.
According to family members and teachers, Nathaniel was studious and generally well-behaved, a student chosen to help counsel other kids when they had difficulties.
"It never dawned on me that this could be my child to do such an act," his mother, Polly Josey-Whitefield, told a reporter.
Nathaniel Sr., who does not live with the boy's mother, says he heard the news from his brother. "I immediately began to pray that it wasn't actually Nate they were talking about. What made me realize it was true was my father got on the phone and he was crying."
Apparently, Nathaniel had stolen the gun from the home of a relative days before the shooting. Police say a couple of his buddies now admit that Nathaniel had shown them the gun three days earlier, but they did not inform any adults. If Nathaniel was angry enough to shoot a teacher after being sent home from school for tossing water balloons, police still don't believe he had anything that resembled a plan.
One of the few adults with certain answers in this tragedy is State Attorney Barry Krischer, who is determined to try Nathaniel as an adult on charges of murder and aggravated assault. Never mind that Nathaniel has no prior criminal record. Never mind that the boy's apparent lack of remorse in the hours following his arrest was more likely, according to psychologists, a state of shock.
After all, like most boys his age, Nathaniel has probably logged countless hours in front of violent movies, TV shows and video games. And the deaths in those didn't yield up bitter long-term consequences, did they? So why should Nathaniel expect pulling a trigger on a real-life gun should permanently alter his life and that of another family?
But Krischer is unmoved. He is playing to the hilt his role as symbol of another strange tendency in American society - the inability to distinguish a 13-year-old offender from a 23-year-old. Prosecutors such as Krischer seem to believe they best serve society by throwing violent juvenile offenders into facilities with hardened adult criminals, thereby ensuring that those youngsters will eventually leave prison even more deranged than they went in.
What a weird culture this is. We allow our children's leisure hours to be saturated with violent images. We acquire guns as if they're tennis rackets or golf clubs - about 200 million firearms for 260 million people - and leave them lying around as if they're spare change. And we reserve a special recognition for the criminal who fascinates us even as he reviles. Nathaniel seems just the kind of kid such a culture would produce.
Cynthia Tucker is the editor of the Atlanta Constitution editorial pages.
©2000 KnightRidder.com
So much for the "he killed by accident" tactic.
http://web.philly.com/content/inquirer/2000/06/05/opinion/TUCKER05.htm
Commentary / Cynthia Tucker
Boy who killed his teacher is reflection of our culture
By Cynthia Tucker
'Just watch. I'll be all over the news."
Thirteen-year-old Nathaniel Brazill reportedly gave that warning to a classmate hours before he took a .25-caliber semiautomatic pistol to school and shot a teacher to death on May 26. His utterance, if true, may give us more insight into Nathaniel's horrendous act than anything we are likely to hear about his family, his grades or his ambitions.
In a society that values celebrity more than honor, notoriety more than accomplishment, young Nathaniel had learned that committing a horrible crime could gain him instant and widespread recognition. His status on the honor roll couldn't do that. Nor could his perfect attendance record. But shooting Barry Grunow, a beloved English teacher at Nathaniel's Palm Beach County, Fla., middle school, could and did.
"This is a tragedy," said Nathaniel Brazill Sr. "I am so sorry for the family of this teacher - so sorry." Neither months of counseling nor years of pondering are ever likely to yield any more clues to Nathaniel's crime. He is, after all, just a child - impulsive, easily swayed, eager to impress his pals, blissfully ignorant of long-term consequences. And children, especially adolescents, can be so difficult to decipher.
According to family members and teachers, Nathaniel was studious and generally well-behaved, a student chosen to help counsel other kids when they had difficulties.
"It never dawned on me that this could be my child to do such an act," his mother, Polly Josey-Whitefield, told a reporter.
Nathaniel Sr., who does not live with the boy's mother, says he heard the news from his brother. "I immediately began to pray that it wasn't actually Nate they were talking about. What made me realize it was true was my father got on the phone and he was crying."
Apparently, Nathaniel had stolen the gun from the home of a relative days before the shooting. Police say a couple of his buddies now admit that Nathaniel had shown them the gun three days earlier, but they did not inform any adults. If Nathaniel was angry enough to shoot a teacher after being sent home from school for tossing water balloons, police still don't believe he had anything that resembled a plan.
One of the few adults with certain answers in this tragedy is State Attorney Barry Krischer, who is determined to try Nathaniel as an adult on charges of murder and aggravated assault. Never mind that Nathaniel has no prior criminal record. Never mind that the boy's apparent lack of remorse in the hours following his arrest was more likely, according to psychologists, a state of shock.
After all, like most boys his age, Nathaniel has probably logged countless hours in front of violent movies, TV shows and video games. And the deaths in those didn't yield up bitter long-term consequences, did they? So why should Nathaniel expect pulling a trigger on a real-life gun should permanently alter his life and that of another family?
But Krischer is unmoved. He is playing to the hilt his role as symbol of another strange tendency in American society - the inability to distinguish a 13-year-old offender from a 23-year-old. Prosecutors such as Krischer seem to believe they best serve society by throwing violent juvenile offenders into facilities with hardened adult criminals, thereby ensuring that those youngsters will eventually leave prison even more deranged than they went in.
What a weird culture this is. We allow our children's leisure hours to be saturated with violent images. We acquire guns as if they're tennis rackets or golf clubs - about 200 million firearms for 260 million people - and leave them lying around as if they're spare change. And we reserve a special recognition for the criminal who fascinates us even as he reviles. Nathaniel seems just the kind of kid such a culture would produce.
Cynthia Tucker is the editor of the Atlanta Constitution editorial pages.
©2000 KnightRidder.com