Blackhawk cylinder diameters?

B

Butzbach

New member
Is the cylinder on a Blackhawk in .357 the same diameter as one in .45 Colt?

I bought a nice used holster for my BH .357 and it’s roaming around in it a little more than I’d like. Thinking it may have been stretched by a .45. (Or maybe just a Super Blackhawk?)

Enquiring minds want to know.
 
The regular New Model BHs .357, .45 Colt, and .44Mag are on the same large frame with the same diameter cylinder. Same as the original Vaquero.

Then there is the New Model medium frame BHs with flattops (.357, .44Special, and .45 Colt) to distinguish them. Same size as the New Vaqueros. So if you have a flattop .357 it is a bit smaller. Flattop means there is no protective ears around the rear sight. Also the medium frame flattops all start with 3 digit serial number xxx-yyyyy instead of two digit xx-yyyyy as well. Oh, and if talking three screw Old Model BH .357, then it is also on the medium frame. All Old Model .357s are on the medium frame. Why they were popular to convert to .44 Special in their day.

Here is a article where there is a table of the cylinder size: Gunblast New Vaquero . Old Vaquero is same as (S)BH in that table. Hope that helps.
 
Last edited:
rclark said:
The regular New Model BHs .357, .45 Colt, and .44Mag are on the same large frame with the same diameter cylinder. Same as the original Vaquero.

Then there is the New Model medium frame BHs with flattops (.357, .44Special, and .45 Colt) to distinguish them. Same size as the New Vaqueros. So if you have a flattop .357 it is a bit smaller. Flattop means there is no protective ears around the rear sight. Also the medium frame flattops all start with 3 digit serial number xxx-yyyyy instead of two digit xx-yyyyy as well. Oh, and if talking three screw Old Model BH .357, then it is also on the medium frame. All Old Model .357s are on the medium frame. Why they were popular to convert to .44 Special in their day.

Here is a article where there is a table of the cylinder size: Gunblast New Vaquero . Old Vaquero is same as (S)BH in that table. Hope that helps.
Click to expand...
Thanks very much for the info. I’ve made a couple of runs at trying to understand the evolution of BH frames but the info never seems to stick. Mine is a medium frame 3 screw old model BH.

Any tips on shrinking a holster?
 
how I shrink a holster:
1. Wrap pistol in a rabbit fur, fur side in
2. Stuff gun in holster
3. Enjoy new fur lined holster!

You can get more fancy from there, but I like rabbit fur.
 
No tip ( excuse to buy a new one? ) . I have a 120 holster made for the large frame New Models. But I still stuff my New Vaquero and other flattops in it. A little 'loose', but the holster has a hold down strap that goes over the back of the revolver, so I don't worry about it.
 
Last edited:
rclark said:
No tip ( excuse to buy ahttps://www.gunbroker.com/item/917315854#carousel-modal-view-item new one? ) . I have a 120 holster made for the large frame New Models. But I still stuff my New Vaquero and other flattops in it. A little 'loose', but the holster has a hold down strap that goes over the back of the revolver, so I don't worry about it.
Click to expand...
Mine is a very nice NOS George Lawrence suede lined with a half flap. It will do for range walks to the target which is why I bought it.
 
Last edited:
Sounds like a nice holster! I have another holster (the 'Shootist' from Simply Rugged) on the way, along with a matching gun belt. Decided it was about time, as the 2.5" gun belt I have ... only fits a skinny teenager.... :) . I have been just hanging holsters on my pants belt which sometimes in a pain.
 
Thanks very much for the info. I’ve made a couple of runs at trying to understand the evolution of BH frames but the info never seems to stick. Mine is a medium frame 3 screw old model BH.
Click to expand...

'Yours doesn't fit right because the Old Model 357's are on a smaller Colt sized frame.
 
The original Blackhawk was made on a Colt SAA size frame (roughly). These were all "Flattops".

When Ruger brought out the .44 Magnum ('56), they still used that frame size, but lengthened the cylinder window a bit for the long .44 Mag round.

In 59 Ruger began producing the Super Blackhawk, on an all new frame of larger size, with the hump on the topstrap protecting the rear sight base. Same frame they are still using today.

Ruger built both the .44 Blackhawk and the Super Blackhawk until about 64 when the original flattop frame was dropped. And some time after that, began making the Blackhawk on the large (super blackhawk) frame. These are the "3 screw" Blackhawks, not flattops and are all on the large frame.

In 73 Ruger introduced the "New Model" guns both Blackhawk and Super Blackhawk, all on the same large frame with the transfer bar system.

When Ruger wanted a gun to fit the Cowboy action rules (fixed sights) they used that same large frame as the Blackhawk, just recontoured the topstrap to a fixed sight gun, and named it the Vaquero.

Ruger eventually dropped the Vaquero, replacing it wth a Colt size gun, named the "New Vaquero".

And, now, Ruger is also offering a recreation of their original Flattop models, but with the "new model" lockwork. These are Colt size guns.

So, there are 5 different "Blackhawks" possible, the original Blackhawk, the original Blackhawk in .44 Magnum, the large frame Blackhawk with the original Colt type lockwork, (3 screw) the new model Blackhawk (large frame, transfer bar) and the new Flattop model with the transfer bar lockwork.

As far as I know, none of the original Flattops was ever made in .45 Colt. Some of the large frame Blackhawks with the colt type lockwork were (approx 70-73) and after 73 all .45 Colts were large frame new model Blackhawks.

Until recently when Ruger brought back the smaller Flattop frame size Blackhawk and chambered it in .45 Colt.

clear as mud now? :rolleyes:
 
When Ruger brought out the .44 Magnum ('56), they still used that frame size, but lengthened the cylinder window a bit for the long .44 Mag round.
Click to expand...
Some of your info is wrong. The original 44 mag Blackhawk was a large frame. There was never a mid frame 44 mag. The built three prototypes on the mid frame and they blew with proof loads. The Super frame and cylinder are the same size and strength. The only function difference is the longer Dragoon grip frame.

ALL Old Model 357's are on the Colt sized medium frame. ALL other Old Model Blackhawks are large frame.

The flat tops went away in 1962. They added the protective ears around the rear sight, substituted the XR3 for the XR3-RED grip frame.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top